Fine Japanese Calligraphy

The Art of Master Japanese Calligrapher Eri Takase

0

我武者羅 gamushara Reckless

This is a philological study of the Japanese word 我武者羅 (gamushara), reckless. It spans the record from a 1658 haikai pun on a hothead pulling armor over his head to the word's life today in song titles and sumo prose, and examines how a Meiji spelling in borrowed characters carried an Edo word for blame into a modern one for praise.

我武者羅 · gamushara · Reckless — headlong, all-out; an Edo slang word for the hothead, dressed in Meiji characters, that has turned from blame to praise

Abstract

我武者羅, gamushara, is a native Japanese word for the hothead written in borrowed characters that mean nothing on their own. On record from a 1658 haikai pun and on Chikamatsu's puppet stage around 1700 as がむしゃ, it took the suffix ら in the nineteenth century and the decorative character 羅 to write it, becoming a dictionary headword by 1915. Its sense has drifted from blame, an Edo word for heedless violence, toward praise, the modern word for all-out effort; English reckless keeps only the older half.

Overview

The sense. Edo slang, standard by the 1940s; blame that has become praise. The base is the harsher word: the national dictionary defines it as hot blood; heedless violence; doing a thing any old how, and the 1922 dictionary that lists it labels it slang [1][2]. The suffixed word is softer and has kept softening: forcing a thing through without thought for before or after, with the examples an all-out attack and to work flat out, and a synonym list that is the vocabulary of effort, single-minded, undistracted, giving one's all [3]. The modern idiom dictionary files it under to devote oneself and to give one's all [4]. English reckless is heedless of consequences and is a verdict; headlong and hell-for-leather are the same speed without the verdict. The Japanese word has moved from the first toward the second over the last century.

The words. None of the four characters means what the word means. The dictionaries derive the base, gamusha, with a question mark, from an older word for self-greed, and say plainly that 武者, warrior, was borrowed for its sound; ra is a suffix and 羅 the character borrowed to write it [5]. The word is usually written in kana [1][6].

The text in English. There is no nineteenth-century English for this word. Hepburn's three dictionaries and Brinkley's do not carry it, which fits its label as slang; the missionaries did not take the word down [7]. The English it has is the modern dictionaries': reckless; daredevil; frantic; foolhardy, and, for the person, daredevil, madcap, hothead, swashbuckler [8]. The house's Reckless is the first of those glosses.

The historical record

Not Chinese. The word is Japanese through and through; the Chinese corpus has no such string [9].

1658. Its oldest witness is a haikai verse of 1658, a New Year's pun on a hothead pulling armor on over his head [1].

Around 1700, Chikamatsu. Chikamatsu used it on the puppet stage around 1700, and two of his uses were read here at the page: the hotheads, hot with the chase, crying leave none alive [10], and, of a fierce mother, a hothead true to her name [11]; the dictionaries cite three more of his plays [2]. It was a person-word, a gamusha fellow, and Edo popular fiction kept it for the lawless hothead.

1896, and 1898. The suffix arrived in the nineteenth century. By 1896 a dictionary was using gamushara to explain a word that had gone out of use, glossing a Genroku-era term as gamushara, helter-skelter, violent [12]; two years later a novelist spelled it with the character for et cetera and glossed it the sort who thinks of neither before nor after [3].

1911 to 1943. The spelling on this design, with 羅, is in a storytellers' magazine of 1911 [13], a dictionary headword in 1915 [14], a girls' school reader's vocabulary in 1926 [15], listed among the dialect words of two Mikawa towns in the early 1930s [16], and in the national broadcaster's pronunciation dictionary of 1943 [6].

The 1920s translators, and 1925. The translators of the 1920s reached for it: for Dostoevsky's Varvara Petrovna [17], for Sophocles' Creon, who insists I am not a gamushara tyrant [18], for Drinkwater's Lincoln [19]. The poet Kitahara Hakushū used it in 1925 as a reproach [20].

Today. Japanese today uses the word on the other side of the ledger. Japanese Wikipedia's articles on it are led by a heavy-metal album and a run of song titles [21], a sumo writer in 1962 uses it for a headlong pursuit [22], and the dictionary's synonyms are words of admiration [3]. A rendering must choose which end to stand on: headlong or all-out stands nearer the living word, reckless nearer the Edo one. The page's second gloss, proceeding single-mindedly without regard to consequences, stands in the honest middle.

A reading

This is an Edo slang word dressed in Meiji characters, and both halves of that sentence are to its credit. The thing itself is on Chikamatsu's stage: the man who rushes a fight. The characters came later, once a spoken word needed writing, and they are on the dictionary's page by 1915, which is old enough for a brush. What has changed is the verdict. The Edo word was blame; the word in a broadcaster's list, a sumo report and a rack of song titles is praise, the all-out effort Japanese admires and names without irony. English reckless keeps only the blame. So the four characters are exact for the word, and reckless is exact for the word's older half.

References

  1. 「我武者」, 精選版日本国語大辞典・デジタル大辞泉 (citing 俳諧鸚鵡集, 1658), at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/我武者
  2. 落合直文, 言泉, 1922, scan 430, pp. 834–835. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/969159/1/430
  3. 「我武者羅」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/我武者羅
  4. 我武者羅, jitenon 四字熟語辞典. https://yoji.jitenon.jp/cat/search.php?getdata=我武者羅&search=contain
  5. がむしゃら, gogen-yurai.jp. https://gogen-yurai.jp/gamusyara/
  6. 日本放送協会, 日本語アクセント辞典, 1943, scan 81, p. 145. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1126379/1/81
  7. Hepburn, A Japanese and English Dictionary (1867, 1872; fourth edition, 1888); Brinkley, An Unabridged Japanese-English Dictionary (1896) — no headword found.
  8. JMdict, WordNet, at Weblio 英和・和英辞典. https://ejje.weblio.jp/content/我武者羅
  9. Chinese Text Project, post-Han corpus search, 我武者 (0). https://ctext.org/post-han?searchu=我武者
  10. 近松, 最明寺殿百人上臈, 近松時代浄瑠璃集, 1896, scan 222, pp. 8–9. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/876715/1/222
  11. 近松, 薩摩歌, 近松世話浄瑠璃集, 1897, scan 52, p. 90. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1883006/1/52
  12. 藤井乙男・草野清民, 帝国大辞典, 1896, scan 229, p. 446. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2387590/1/229
  13. 講談倶楽部, 侠客殿様源次, 1911, scan 57. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/889858/1/57
  14. 上田万年・松井簡治, 大日本国語辞典, 1915, scan 488, pp. 950–951. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/954645/1/488
  15. 女子副読本備考, 1926, scan 6. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/925539/1/6
  16. 岡崎市史, 1930, scan 40; 刈谷町誌, 1932, scan 261. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1240764/1/40 · https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1209008/1/261
  17. ドストイェーフスキー全集, 1921, scan 156. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/958992/1/156
  18. 中村吉蔵 (訳), 希臘悲劇六曲, 1922, scan 207. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/968163/1/207
  19. ドリンクウォーター, エブラハム・リンカーン, 1924, scan 47. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/977319/1/47
  20. 北原白秋, 季節の窓, 1925, scan 28. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1016715/1/28
  21. Japanese Wikipedia, full-text search, 我武者羅. https://ja.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?search=%22我武者羅%22&ns0=1&fulltext=1
  22. 村松梢風, 両国の川風, 1962, scan 128. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1648988/1/128

Authors