Fine Japanese Calligraphy

The Art of Master Japanese Calligrapher Eri Takase

0

桃李満門 tōri manmon A Gate Full of Excellent Pupils

桃李満門 (tōri manmon), peach and plum fill the gate, says that a person has many excellent pupils. The figure is Chinese, and in the National Diet Library's full text its oldest Japanese use is a Zen letter of 1398. This study follows it from a Han warning about whom one plants to a tribute said of teachers.

Abstract

桃李満門, read tōri manmon, or entered in the dictionaries as 桃李門に満つ, tōri mon ni mitsu, peach and plum fill the gate, says that a person has many excellent pupils [1]. The figure is Chinese, peach and plum as the people one raises and puts forward: two Han collections tell it as a warning, choose before you plant, the 資治通鑑 gives the line to the Tang minister Di Renjie 狄仁傑, whose answer refuses the credit, and the four characters stand together in a Chinese text dated 1169 [2][3][4][5]. In Japan the oldest use the National Diet Library's full text gives is a Zen monk's letter of 1398 to a new abbot of Tōfuku-ji 東福寺, which already echoes Di Renjie's answer; from the eighteenth century the phrase is said of teachers, of Kinoshita Jun'an 木下順庵's school by Uno Meika 宇野明霞, of a village schoolmaster by the monk Gesshō 月性, of the Zen master Shaku Sōen 釈宗演 in an essay written the day after he died, and in 1929 Tokutomi Sohō 徳富蘇峰 brushed the four characters in three sizes as the title of an album of a teacher's friends and pupils [6][7][8][9][10][11]. My reading, signed below, is that the phrase is a tribute said of a teacher, and that the tradition behind it keeps its own caution about whom one plants.

Overview

The sense. The デジタル大辞泉 enters the phrase under its Japanese reading: 桃李(とうり)門(もん)に満(み)つ 《「資治通鑑」から》門下生にすぐれた人物がたくさんいることをいう, (from the 資治通鑑) said when there are many excellent people among one's pupils. The 精選版 日本国語大辞典: とうり【桃李】門(もん)に満(み)つ 優秀な門下生がたくさんいる。門下に秀才が多いことのたとえ, there are many outstanding pupils; a figure for having many talented people among one's followers [1]. Neither entry has the four characters as a headword. JMdict has 桃李満門 tōri manmon with the gloss gathering of excellent and capable people, which keeps the excellence and drops the gate [12].

The words. 桃 is the peach and 李 the plum, and 桃李 together are both trees; 満 is to fill and 門 the gate, the house of a teacher or a patron. The 日本国語大辞典's second sense of 桃李 is the people an examiner passed, the talent one has put forward, one's own pupils, and its earliest Japanese example of that sense is the 蔭凉軒日録, a Zen diary, under the third month of 1489, as the dictionary quotes it: 皆輿桃李也 [13]. The dictionaries keep apart a neighbor with the same two trees, 桃李もの言わざれども下自ら蹊を成す, peach and plum say nothing, yet a path forms beneath them, of a person of virtue to whom others come of themselves [14]. That proverb is about the teacher's character; this phrase is about the pupils.

The two readings. Both are in print. Tokutomi Sohō wrote the ruby たうりもんにみつ beside the four characters in 1929, the reading the dictionaries keep, and Takahashi Sōan 高橋箒庵 wrote とうりまんもん beside them in 1928 [11][15]. JMdict enters tōri manmon [12].

What follows. The historical record reads the Chinese sources of the figure, its four characters in China, its coming into Japanese with the Zen monks, the Edo schools, the Meiji and Taishō occasions, the brush, and the English. A reading is mine.

The historical record

Planting peach and plum

The oldest tellings read for this history are a story in two Han collections. In the 韓詩外傳 of Han Ying 韓嬰, a man named 子質 has fallen from office and tells his lord he will never again do a kindness for anyone, because those he helped have turned against him [2][16]. The lord answers:

夫春樹桃李,夏得陰其下,秋得食其實。春樹蒺藜,夏不可採其葉,秋得其刺焉。由此觀之,在所樹也。今子之所樹,非其人也,故君子先擇而後種也。

If you plant peach and plum in spring, in summer you have shade beneath them and in autumn you eat their fruit. If you plant the caltrop in spring, in summer you cannot pick its leaves, and in autumn you get its thorns. So it depends on what you plant. What you planted were not the right people: the gentleman chooses first and plants after [2]. The 說苑 of Liu Xiang 劉向 tells the same story of 陽虎, who complains that half the men at court are men he set there and every one has turned on him, and it ends 自今以來,擇人而樹,毋已樹而擇之, from now on, choose the person and then plant; do not plant and then choose [3][17]. In both, peach and plum are the people one raises, and the lesson is a warning to the one who raises them.

Di Renjie's answer

The line the dictionaries name comes from the 資治通鑑, the chronicle Sima Guang 司馬光 completed in 1084 [18]. Under the year 700 it tells how the minister Di Renjie (630–700) recommended Yao Yuanchong 姚元崇 and some dozens of others, nearly all of whom became famous ministers [4][19]:

或謂仁傑曰:「天下桃李,悉在公門矣。」仁傑曰:「薦賢爲國,非爲私也。」

Someone said to Renjie, "All the peach and plum under heaven are at your gate." Renjie said, "I recommend the worthy for the state, not for myself." The source line has 公門, your gate, not 滿門, and the man praised turns the praise away. The 桃李 here are men put forward for office, not pupils.

Two Tang poets give the figure its other homes. Liu Yuxi 劉禹錫 (772–842), on the list of those who passed an examination, writes 一日聲名遍天下滿城桃李屬春官, in one day their names go all over the empire; the peach and plum of the whole city belong to the examiner [20][21]. Bai Juyi 白居易 (772–846), answering a minister's poem on planting flowers at his hall, writes 令公桃李滿天下,何用堂前更種花, your peach and plum fill the empire: why plant more flowers before your hall? [22][23].

Four characters, 1169

The four characters stand together in a record of a pavilion at Jiankang (Nanjing), written by Zhang Chun 張椿, who calls himself a man of the governor's gate, and signed 乾道己丑中秋日, the mid-autumn day of 1169 [5]. A guest says to the governor, Shi Zhengzhi 史正志: 四方之士知公推轂後進桃李滿門願一見公者日有其人, the gentlemen of the four quarters know that you push the young men forward and your gate is full of peach and plum, and every day someone wishes to see you. It is a patron's gate, as in Di Renjie's story. The record is printed in the gazetteer of Jiankang of the Jingding era, as the Siku quanshu transcribes it [5]. In the Ming the four characters go into poems for teachers, among them a poem seeing off a county schoolmaster, 桃李滿門培植久, peach and plum fill your gate, long tended, and an elegy for a teacher, 栽成桃李滿門墻, the peach and plum you planted fill the wall of your gate [24][25].

A Ming doubt: the planting story is the root

The Ming scholar He Mengchun 何孟春 asked where the figure came from, in his 餘冬序録, printed with a preface of 1528 [26]. People say 桃李 of the men one recommends, he wrote, 皆本唐人謂狄梁公天下桃李皆在公門之說此說恐非首創, all take it from the Tang saying of Di Renjie, that all the peach and plum under heaven are at his gate; this is probably not where it began. He quotes the 說苑's planting story, then 乃知此其事祖也, so we know this is the root of the matter, and he adds a Tang poem mocking the minister Pei Du 裴度: 破却千家作一池不栽桃李種薔薇薔薇花落秋風起荊棘滿庭君始知, you broke a thousand houses to make one pond; you planted roses, not peach and plum; when the roses fall and the autumn wind rises, then you will know, with thorns filling your court [26]. The デジタル大辞泉 today gives the 資治通鑑 as the source, and a dictionary of 1922 gave the 說苑 [1][27]. The tradition holds both, and so does this history.

Into Japanese with the Zen monks, 1398

The oldest use of the four characters the National Diet Library's full text gives is in Japanese Zen prose [6][7]. On the first day of the eighth month of 1398, Zaisen Kijō 在先希譲 (1335–1403) entered Tōfuku-ji 東福寺 as its abbot, and the Zen monk Taihaku Shingen 太白真玄 (1357–1415) wrote a 道舊疏 for him, the letter of congratulation sent on such an installation by a monk of the same generation [6][28][29][30]. In its parallel prose the letter praises him as a man around whom, wherever one goes, one sees peach and plum filling his gate, and near whom one smells orchids in the room. Earlier in the same letter it says and moreover it is for the state, not for oneself, which is Di Renjie's answer [6]. The text is printed in the 大日本史料 of 1930 under the date of the installation, from Taihaku's collection 峨眉鴉臭集, and in the 五山文学全集 of 1908 [6][7]. So the oldest Japanese use found by this instrument already carries the story's own caution, beside the figure that the caution refused.

The Edo schools

Kinoshita Jun'an's gate. The Confucian scholar Uno Meika (1698–1745), answering a letter from the monk 玄海, argued that Kyoto had not lacked men of learning [8][31]. In the print of his writings, which the library's record dates by its preface to 1748, the letter reads:

之學亦自藤先生而木公桃李滿門則海内之學多淵源于洛

… his learning too came from Master Fujiwara; and with Master Ki's gate full of peach and plum, learning across the land draws its source from Kyoto [8]. 木公, Master Ki, is Kinoshita Jun'an (1621–1699), named in the line before as 順菴木公 [8][32]. Hara Nensai 原念斎's lives of the Confucian scholars, the 先哲叢談 of 1816, took the line into its life of Jun'an: 宇士新稱爲桃李滿門, Uno Shishin called it a gate full of peach and plum, and it follows with the list of his pupils, beginning with Arai Hakuseki 新井白石, Muro Kyūsō 室鳩巣 and Amenomori Hōshū 雨森芳洲 under their formal names [33][34][35][36][37]. It is read here in a print of 1880, and the National Diet Library's full text finds the line repeated in Meiji and Taishō histories of Edo learning.

A pupil to his teacher. The monk Gesshō (1817–1858) lodged a second time at 藏園, as the poem's title has it, the private school of Tsuneto Seisō 恒遠醒窓 (1803–1863) in Buzen, which the dictionary calls the 蔵春園, and wrote him a poem [9][38][39]. A note under its title says that a lord was about to invite the master as his honored teacher. It opens:

桃李滿門春色深。育英郷校足靑衿。

Peach and plum fill your gate, the spring color deep; the village school that raises talent has students enough, and it ends by urging him to go: 文章經國君家事。何必栖遲老故林。 letters that govern the state are your house's work; why linger, growing old in your old woods? [9]. The poem was printed in 1869 in the 慨士遺音, in the part of the book given to Gesshō.

Meiji and Taishō: a teacher's occasions

In the National Diet Library's full text, the phrase in Meiji and Taishō is a line for a teacher's occasions: a new school building, an anniversary of teaching, a teacher's sixtieth or eightieth birthday, a teacher's epitaph. Three are told here.

1891. At a banquet at the 櫻雲臺 for the sixtieth birthday of the scholar Kawada Ōkō 川田甕江 (1830–1896), his circle sang a verse with the lines three thousand disciples astonish the neighbors; peach and plum fill the gate, a spring all at once, Confucius's three thousand set beside the gate [40][41]. The verse was printed in a book of model addresses in 1908.

1916. A verse in a magazine of 1916 speaks of a school and takes the phrase in the first person, to set it aside: people say the peach and plum fill my gate; common peaches and vulgar plums are not my wish; I wish to raise pillars for the house and the country [42].

1919. Shaku Sōen (1860–1919), abbot of Engaku-ji, died on the first day of the eleventh month of 1919 [43]. An essay on him, dated the next day and printed in the volume of his addresses of 1920, says [10]:

惟ふに老漢の會下、桃李門に滿つ。然も是れ自然に吸引し來りたるものにして、毫も其の門戸を張大にし …

I think: in the old man's assembly, peach and plum filled the gate. Yet they came drawn of themselves, and not in the least, the sentence goes on, did he spend his strength on purpose to widen his gate [10]. The ruby gives 桃李門 as たうりもん.

The brush

On the ninth of March 1929, back from a visit to Yabakei, Tokutomi Sohō received a long hand-scroll from Dr. Yamazaki 山崎 of the medical college at Kumamoto: letters and writings gathered around the thinker Yokoi Shōnan 横井小楠 (1809–1869), from his friends and his pupils [11][44][45]. Asked for a title and a colophon, he wrote:

題には『桃李滿門』の四字を、大中小三通りに書いた。

For the title I wrote the four characters 桃李滿門 three ways, large, middle and small, with the ruby たうりもんにみつ beside them, and he set down a poem as the colophon, whose fourth line is 桃李滿其門, peach and plum filled his gate [11]. In his autobiography of 1935 the poem stands under the heading 題桃李滿門帖, with the note that the album was compiled by 山崎默堂 [46]. A transcription of the album was printed in 1929 under the title 桃李満門帖 [47].

The onyomi also served another kind of house. Takahashi Sōan, writing of a tea friend's good year in 1928, a new villa, a new house and an appointment to the House of Peers, wrote 家庭圓滿、桃李滿門、春風春水一時に來るの有樣, the household content, peach and plum filling the gate, spring wind and spring water come all at once, with the ruby とうりまんもん [15][48]. There the phrase is the good fortune of a house, not a teacher's.

In English

The English of the phrase read for this history is the Chinese dictionaries'. A Dictionary of Chinese Idiomatic Phrases (1964) gives 滿門桃李 as A whole family of peaches and plums — a lot of pupils; many disciples, citing the Book of the Tang on Di Renjie, and a neighbor, 桃李盈庭, as Peaches and plums fill up the court-yard — many pupils, as the Internet Archive's full-text index gives it [49]. No romanization of the Japanese reading came up in the Internet Archive's full text [50]. JMdict's gathering of excellent and capable people is the one English gloss of the Japanese four characters found [12].

A reading

I read 桃李満門 as a tribute to a teacher, said of him by others. That is how the Japanese witnesses read for this history use it, Takahashi Sōan's household of 1928 aside: Uno Meika of Kinoshita Jun'an, Gesshō of his host's school, a circle at its teacher's sixtieth birthday, an essay on Shaku Sōen, Sohō of Yokoi Shōnan's friends and pupils. The one verse I read that uses it in the first person, in 1916, quotes it as what people say and turns it down.

The tradition behind the figure keeps a caution, and I think it is the part of the phrase most worth keeping. The Han stories say to choose before you plant; Di Renjie says he planted for the state and not for himself; He Mengchun's Tang poem says that a man who plants roses for show gets thorns in his court; the essay on Sōen says his gate filled of itself and he never worked to widen it. On a teacher's wall the four characters wish him the pupils; the stories under them say what makes a gate worth filling.

The phrase fits a dōjō as a wish for its teacher and a tribute to him. That is my reading of where it hangs well; no witness read for this history puts the phrase at the opening of a dōjō.

Notes

The Japanese floor. The 日本国語大辞典 gives 1489 for 桃李 as one's pupils and no earliest example for the phrase; the 1398 letter is the oldest Japanese use of the four characters in the National Diet Library's full text [13][1][6].

Not a dōjō custom. Two books of model addresses, of 1908 and 1915, print the 1891 birthday verse, and both also print an address for opening a fencing hall; the verse is not in that address as the library's full text gives it [40].

桃李満門 and 桃李不言. The second is the proverb about a person of virtue drawing others without a word; it shares the two trees and not the sense [14].

Sources not seen

『大日本史料』 第7編之3, 東京帝国大学, 1930, National Diet Library pid 12211843, and 上村観光 校訂, 『五山文学全集』 vol. 3, 1908, National Diet Library pid 892699, both served only inside Japan [6][7]. The page image of Taihaku Shingen's 1398 letter would settle its characters, which the two prints' text layers give differently in places.

『祝辞弔祭文一万題』, 1908, National Diet Library pid 865650, and 『文章百科全書』, 1915, pid 945276, served only inside Japan or not served [40]. The page image would settle the wording of the 1891 verse.

『東亜研究』, 1916, National Diet Library pid 1486867, served only inside Japan [42]. The page would give the writer's name and the occasion of the 1916 verse.

A reader with access to any of these is invited to write to Takase Studios at Tim@Takase.com.

References

  1. 「桃李門に満つ」, デジタル大辞泉 and 精選版 日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/桃李門に満つ-581620
  2. 韓嬰, 『韓詩外傳』 卷第七, at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (427523). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/韓詩外傳/卷第7
  3. 劉向, 『說苑』 卷六 復恩, at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (2345653). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/說苑/卷06
  4. 司馬光, 『資治通鑑』 卷207, 久視元年, at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (1756151). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/資治通鑑/卷207
  5. 張椿, 青溪閣 記, 乾道己丑 (1169), in 周應合, 『景定建康志』 卷21, the 四庫全書 text at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (762084). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/景定建康志_(四庫全書本)/卷21
  6. 東京大学史料編纂所 編, 『大日本史料』 第7編之3, 東京大学, 1930, under 応永5年8月1日, quoting 『峨眉鴉臭集』, snippet view, National Diet Library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/12211843
  7. 上村観光 編, 『五山文学全集』 3, 裳華房, 1908, snippet view, National Diet Library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/892699
  8. 宇野鼎 (明霞), 『明霞先生遺稿』, vol. 2 of the NDL copy, 寛延1 (1748) 序, 「答玄海上人書」, scan 96. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2559752/1/96
  9. 吉田松陰 and 月性, 『慨士遺音』 前編 巻之下, 都文堂, 1869, 「再寓藏園賦呈醒窓恒遠先生」, scan 24. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/899287/1/24
  10. 釈宗演, 『最後の一喝』, 帝国出版協会, 1920, the essay 「宗演老漢」, p. 6, scan 137, dated at scan 139. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/963186/1/137
  11. 徳富猪一郎 (蘇峰), 『台湾遊記』, 民友社, 1929, pp. 156–157, scan 119. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1175482/1/119
  12. JMdict (EDRDG), the release file of 1 October 2026, entry 2828451 桃李満門.
  13. 「桃李」, デジタル大辞泉 and 精選版 日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/桃李-581618
  14. 「桃李もの言わざれども下自ら蹊を成す」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/桃李もの言わざれども下自ら蹊を成す-581619
  15. 高橋義雄 (箒庵), 『大正茶道記』 丙寅, 慶文堂書店, 1928, p. 366, scan 198. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1192294/1/198
  16. 「韓詩外伝」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/韓詩外伝-48826
  17. 「説苑」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/説苑-85520
  18. 「資治通鑑」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/資治通鑑-73235
  19. 「狄仁傑」, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/狄仁傑-100795
  20. 劉禹錫, 「宣上人遠寄和禮部王侍郎放榜後詩因而繼和」, 『御定全唐詩』 卷359, the 四庫全書 text at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (775292). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/御定全唐詩_(四庫全書本)/卷359
  21. 「劉禹錫」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/劉禹錫-149497
  22. 白居易, 「奉和令公綠野堂種花」, from 『全唐詩』 卷456, at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (829323). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/奉和令公綠野堂種花
  23. 「白居易」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/白居易-113647
  24. 黃仲昭, 『未軒文集』 卷10, 「送劉景輝先生敎諭萬安」, the 四庫全書 text at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (784569). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/未軒文集_(四庫全書本)/卷10
  25. 韓雍, 『襄毅文集』 卷4, 「輓豐城静菴楊先生」, the 四庫全書 text at zh.wikisource, the revision read October 2026 (708803). https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/襄毅文集_(四庫全書本)/卷04
  26. 何孟春, 『餘冬序録』, vol. 10 of the NDL copy, 嘉靖7 (1528) 序刊, scan 24. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2575320/1/24
  27. 落合直文, 『言泉 : 日本大辞典』 第3巻, 改修版, 大倉書店, 1922, 「桃李門に滿つ」, scan 388. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/969161/1/388
  28. 「在先希譲」, デジタル版 日本人名大辞典+Plus, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/在先希譲-1076627
  29. 「太白真玄」, デジタル版 日本人名大辞典+Plus, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/太白真玄-1086613
  30. 「入寺疏」, 改訂新版 世界大百科事典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/入寺疏-1386631
  31. 「宇野明霞」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/宇野明霞-35034
  32. 「木下順庵」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/木下順庵-16209
  33. 原念斎 and 東条琴台, 『先哲叢談』 巻之3, 4, 松田幸助等, 1880, scan 16. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/778287/1/16
  34. 「原念斎」 and 「先哲叢談」, 精選版 日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/原念斎-1102658 · https://kotobank.jp/word/先哲叢談-88644
  35. 「新井白石」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/新井白石-14405
  36. 「室鳩巣」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/室鳩巣-17058
  37. 「雨森芳洲」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/雨森芳洲-27423
  38. 「月性」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/月性-59611
  39. 「恒遠醒窓」, デジタル版 日本人名大辞典+Plus, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/恒遠醒窓-1092463
  40. 大畑裕, 『祝辞弔祭文一万題』, 修学堂, 1908, National Diet Library pid 865650; and 山岸辰蔵 編, 『文章百科全書』, 脩学堂書店, 1915, pid 945276; both snippet view, National Diet Library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/865650
  41. 「川田甕江」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/川田甕江-48285
  42. 『東亜研究』 6(5), 東亜学術研究会, 1916-05, snippet view, National Diet Library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1486867
  43. 「釈宗演」, 日本大百科全書 (ニッポニカ) and 20世紀日本人名事典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/釈宗演-18291
  44. 「徳富蘇峰」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/徳富蘇峰-19128
  45. 「横井小楠」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/横井小楠-22088
  46. 徳富猪一郎 (蘇峰), 『蘇峰自伝』, 中央公論社, 1935, p. 577, scan 313. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1236758/1/313
  47. CiNii Research, 山崎正董, 『肥後西洋医學と横井小楠 ; 桃李満門帖(横井小楠及ひ其の縁故者の筆蹟)釋文』, 1929. https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1970304959950727997
  48. 「高橋箒庵」, 20世紀日本人名事典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/高橋箒庵-1087653
  49. Huang Yen-kai, A Dictionary of Chinese Idiomatic Phrases, The Eton Press, 1964, as the Internet Archive's full-text index gives it (the scans are lent, not open). https://archive.org/details/dictionaryofchin0000unse_y1f1
  50. The Internet Archive full-text search, searched 6 October 2026: tori manmon, toori manmon, tōri manmon, no hits. https://archive.org/search?query=%22tori+manmon%22&sin=TXT

Authors