千客万来 senkyaku banrai Flood of Customers
This is a philological study of the Japanese phrase 千客万来 (senkyaku banrai), a thousand guests, ten thousand comings. It spans the record from the phrase's twin 1811 witnesses, a showman's patter and a senryū that mocked the paper lantern hanging at a shop door, through a century of sign-painters, guidebooks and Meiji speeches, to the dictionaries and Brinkley's 1896 English, and it examines why a phrase made in Japan from Chinese parts, never joined by any Chinese text, is a sign-painter's wish rather than a sage's saying.
Abstract
千客万来, senkyaku banrai, a thousand guests, ten thousand comings, is a Japanese-made phrase of Chinese parts with no Chinese source: the halves exist separately in Tang and Ming texts, but nobody in China joined them. Its two oldest witnesses are both from 1811, a showman's patter and a senryū that jokes about the paper lantern hung at a shop door wishing an endless run of customers. Through the nineteenth century it moved off the lantern into ordinary prose, entered the dictionaries in 1889 as a phrase merchants write to wish their trade well, and reached English in 1896 through Brinkley's literal rendering. It is the oldest and most Japanese of the shop-opening texts, a sign-painter's wish rather than a sage's saying, and nothing stands behind it to look up except a hundred paper lanterns.
Overview
The sense. A Japanese-made phrase of Chinese parts, a thousand guests, ten thousand comings, written on the paper lantern of tea-houses and eating-houses as a wish for trade.
The words. 千 is a thousand and 万 is ten thousand, and here they are not counted but piled up, the way the dictionaries say: many customers, expressed by stacking a thousand on ten thousand [1]. 客 is a guest, and on a shop door a customer. 来 is to come. 千客, a thousand guests, and 万来, ten thousand comings, are each real words, but the dictionaries first cite them alone sixty years after the four together, which is what a set phrase looks like: the halves fall out of it later [1]. Two readings are equally old. Senkyaku is the dictionaries' headword; senkaku, with the older Chinese reading of 客, is the one 三馬 wrote over the word in 1811, and it survives beside the other in every dictionary since [2].
The text in English. The English met the word on the lantern and then forgot it was there.
The historical record
Not from China. The four characters do not appear in any Chinese text at Wikisource, under any of the three spellings [3]. The halves do: a Tang anecdote praises a man who could face a thousand guests and never breach one's name-taboo, and a Ming poem gives a courtesan's lips to ten thousand guests [3]. Nobody in China joined them. In 1897 a Japanese writer walking past the Chinese shops of a treaty port noticed it: where a Japanese shop would hang 千客萬來, the Chinese sign says 富客光臨, may rich guests honor us [4]. A 1944 pocket dictionary gives the Chinese equivalent as a different phrase again [5]. The word was made in Japan, out of Chinese parts, by people who wrote signs.
1811. The lantern. The two oldest witnesses are the same year and do not know each other. 式亭三馬, the Edo comic writer who kept a cosmetics shop and knew a signboard, gives a storytelling-hall showman this patter in his 田舎芝居忠臣蔵: the hall so full the boats overflow, the four quarters not enough — and the letters written on the back of the "lifelong safety" lantern: a thousand guests, ten thousand comings, ten thousand years; truly the Pill of Wealth and Long Life. He wrote senkaku banrai over the characters himself [2]. And the 柳多留, the great senryū anthology, in its fifty-fifth volume the same year: a thousand guests, ten thousand comings — if they all came, that would be a problem [6]. A joke like that only works on a phrase everyone has already seen painted, so the lantern is older than 1811; no known witness reaches it.
1814 to 1862. What the sign-painters wrote. The illustrated popular books of the next fifty years show the phrase in its place and name the trade that put it there. A comic book of 1821: to write 千客万来 on the signboard lantern to wish the shop well is, as you know, the sign-painters' first school [7]. A novel of 1834: "waiting room" on the hanging lantern is the sign-painter's stroke; to write 千客萬来 and "granted, and doubly" greedily is the tea-house custom [8]. A play-book of 1831 ends its preface with the wish itself, may the shop flourish: a thousand guests, ten thousand comings, full house granted — that is the preface [9]. Elsewhere it hangs on a rest-house, an eating-house, a courtesan's talk [10]. Its companions on the lantern were full house granted, ten thousand years, prosperous trade and cash, no haggling, which a later textbook lists together as the famous old lines [11]. Manuscripts of the same age put it on the 雁鍋, the goose-stew house under Ueno hill, and in the Yoshiwara, new every day and every day a thousand guests [12].
1876 to 1898. Off the lantern, into prose. In the Meiji era the phrase leaves the door and becomes an ordinary word for a crowd that keeps coming. A merchant's letter copied into a court record in 1876 wishes a friend prosperity, and may a thousand guests come ten thousand times [13]; a pamphlet of 1884 states it as a fact of a business [14]; a free-trade speech of 1890 promises a port where imports pour in thousand-guests, ten-thousand-comings [15]; an anti-brothel speaker the same year has Socrates promise a courtesan the same [16]; a Kōchi pamphlet of 1893 uses it of the United States, a nation everyone keeps arriving in, black and white, every race mixed [17]. The Tokyo guidebooks of 1897 and 1898 use it of the goose-stew house again, and the 1898 one calls it, with a thousand cranes and ten thousand tortoises, one of the auspicious phrases [18]. 言海, the first modern dictionary, had entered it in 1889 with a label the later dictionaries dropped: not a noun but a phrase, a thousand guests come ten thousand times; a phrase merchants write to wish their trade well [19]. A geisha in an 1896 novel prays it before her luck-shelf [20]; a Buddhist of 1948 disapproves of the same shelf [21]. By the 1930s the National Diet Library has it in two hundred and forty books a decade [22], and the four-character dictionaries take their example from 石川淳 in 1936 [1].
1894, and 1907. The joke explained. The phrase has one sense and two registers. On the lantern it is a wish, in the optative: may guests come without end. In prose it is a description: guests came without end. The Meiji dictionaries keep the wish (written to wish the trade well); the modern ones keep only the description (many customers coming one after another). 尾崎紅葉 saw it from inside a two-room inn in 1894: even as a lie, the lantern's "thousand guests" — a wish so far past the truth it hurts [23]. The joke of 1811 lives in the gap between them, and a Meiji commentator on the senryū spelled it out, in 1907: the places that write 千客萬來 are always cheap eating-houses and cramped country inns; if a thousand guests actually came ten thousand times, as written, they would not be troubled, they would be trampled flat [24]. The phrase's register is humble and hopeful: a small shop's door.
What is not a source. Not a Chinese classic: no text has it [3], and the Chinese shops wrote something else [4]. Not a proverb: it teaches nothing, it wishes. Not a Buddhist or Shinto text, though it hangs on the luck-shelf beside them. Not, on any evidence here, the maneki-neko's phrase: the dictionaries' entries on the beckoning cat and on the 酉の市 rake do not mention it, and no book in the Library's index puts the two together [25]; the pairing may be true of modern shop goods, but it has no witness here.
The word in English
1896. Brinkley's great Japanese-English dictionary does not translate so much as describe: A thousand guests coming ten thousand times, a phrase often found written on a paper lantern hung up in front of tea-houses, public baths, etc. as a kind of charm for attracting customers [26]. 1928. 斎藤 turns the wish into the English a shop would say: The public is cordially invited; Welcome to all! [27]. 1946. The 1946 Standard keeps Welcome to All Visitors and adds the prose sense, they are doing a flourishing business [28].
Today. 研究社's current dictionary has only the prose: be thronged with visitors; that store draws a lot of customers [29]. JMdict gives flood of customers; roaring business, and those two glosses, word for word, are the house title and the page's own phrase [30]. Nobody since 1946 has rendered it as the wish it was written to be.
A reading
This is the oldest and most Japanese of the shop-opening texts, a sign-painter's phrase rather than a sage's, and there is nothing behind it to look up except a hundred paper lanterns. Flood of Customers is right for the prose sense; the lantern's own sense is Brinkley's literal, a thousand guests coming ten thousand times, or 斎藤's Welcome to all! Brushing it for a new shop is the sign-painter's work at its highest, and the word goes back onto the door it was made for.
References
- 千客・万来・千客万来・招き猫・熊手, at kotobank (大辞泉・日国・四字熟語を知る辞典). https://kotobank.jp/word/千客万来 · https://kotobank.jp/word/千客 · https://kotobank.jp/word/万来
- 式亭三馬, 田舎芝居忠臣蔵 (文化8, 1811, printed 1813), in 四大奇書 下, 博文館, 1896, p. 750, scan 385. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1707991/1/385
- zh.wikisource, search for 千客萬來・千客万来・千客萬来 (0 hits) and for the halves 千客・萬客. https://zh.wikisource.org
- 社会百方面, 1897, scan 12. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/798562/1/12
- 井上ポケット日華辞典, 1944, scan 191, at Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/1872029
- 誹風柳多留, vol. 55 (1811), in 誹風柳樽全集, 1924, scan 476. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1879939/1/476
- 萩庵荻声, 茶漬腹名寄評判, 1821, scan 5. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/10301336/1/5
- 三文舎自楽・為永春水, 娘消息, 1834, scan 4. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/8943031/1/4
- 恋川春町二世, 春狂言善悪鏡, 文政14 (1831), scan 3. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/10301512/1/3
- 宝寿玉岩井模様, 1821, scan 5; 黄金花作陸奥, 1826, scan 24; 水馴棹浮名堀河, 1814, scan 28. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/9893382/1/5 · https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/10301197/1/24 · https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/10301603/1/28
- 横山雅男, 統計學, 時事新報出版部, scan 110. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1082681/1/110
- 鵜真似双紙, scan 29; 序跋集覧, scan 4. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2538265/1/29 · https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2554578/1/4
- 太政官日誌, 1876, scan 143. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/787645/1/143
- 仰天嘆論, 1884, scan 13. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/899328/1/13
- 中川虎之助, 演説筆記, 1890, scan 3. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/799494/1/3
- 廃娼同盟会演説集, 1890, scan 15. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/798984/1/15
- 高知土産, 1893, scan 10. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/898461/1/10
- 東京新繁昌記, 1897, scan 94; 最新東京案内記, 1898, scan 204. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/764130/1/94 · https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/764085/1/204
- 大槻文彦, 言海, 1889, scan 353. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/992954/1/353
- 菅屋お婦美, 1896, scan 20. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/886949/1/20
- 高嶋米峰, 仏教の全貌, 1948, scan 74, at Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/1040221
- National Diet Library Digital Collections, next-generation full-text search on 千客万来, by decade. https://lab.ndl.go.jp/dl/
- 尾崎紅葉・小栗風葉, 片靨, 1894, scan 68. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/885893/1/68
- 村上浪六, 川柳自在, 1907, scan 52. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/876166/1/52
- 招き猫・熊手, at kotobank (silent on the phrase). https://kotobank.jp/word/招き猫 · https://kotobank.jp/word/熊手
- F. Brinkley et al., 和英大辞典 (An Unabridged Japanese-English Dictionary), 三省堂, 1896, scan 634. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/903159/1/634
- 斎藤秀三郎, 斎藤和英大辞典, 1928, at Weblio 英和・和英辞典. https://ejje.weblio.jp/content/千客万来
- 竹原常太, スタンダード和英辞典, 1946, scan 419, at Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/1126792
- 研究社, 新和英中辞典, at Weblio 英和・和英辞典. https://ejje.weblio.jp/content/千客万来
- JMdict (EDRDG), 「千客万来」, at jisho.org. https://jisho.org/word/千客万来
