精神統一 seishin tōitsu Concentration
This is a philological study of the Japanese compound 精神統一 (seishin tōitsu), the mind made one. It spans the record from the word's coining in the 1890s by the Japanese scholars building a vocabulary for German philosophy, through the hypnotists', quiet-sitters' and clairvoyance-laboratory fad of the 1910s that a Zen master named and a novelist mocked, to its settling as the plain word of the kendō and kyūdō manuals by the 1930s, and it examines an English history that runs from a 1976 magazine profile through Eri Takase's 1999 essay to the Reiki movement that adopted it after her.
Abstract
精神統一, seishin tōitsu, the mind made one, is a Japanese compound with no Chinese source and no single author, made in the 1890s by the scholars who were building a Japanese vocabulary for German philosophy and psychology. Through the 1910s it became the name of a practice, taken up by hypnotists, quiet-sitters and the subjects of the era's clairvoyance experiments, and named as a fad in 1918 by both a Zen master and a novelist. By the 1920s and 1930s it was the ordinary word in the kendō, kyūdō, tea-ceremony and zazen manuals for the gathering of the mind before an act, and 福来友吉's 1926 definition, every idea working together toward one aim, still fits it. Its English history runs from a 1976 Esquire profile through Eri Takase's 1999 essay for the magazine Kampsport to the Reiki movement that adopted the phrase after her and now accounts for most of its English life.
Overview
The sense. The mind made one: first the philosophers' unity of consciousness, then, from the 1910s, the practitioner's gathering of the mind on one thing before an act — the sense the kendō and kyūdō manuals of the 1920s and 30s settled and the dictionaries give today. Put together, 精神統一 is the mind made one. The compound is not a headword in the two great dictionaries; a dictionary of four-character phrases defines it as to concentrate the mind on one point when doing something and dates its first use to 1918; the standard Japanese-English dictionary gives concentration of mind; mental concentration (on some task) [1]. The Japanese Wikipedia has no article for it and sends the reader to meditation [1].
The words. Seishin tōitsu, two words. Two words, one old and one new to Japanese. 精神 is the mind or spirit; the big dictionary has it from an eighth-century note in the Man'yōshū and grounds it in Zhuangzi, where the spirit flows out in all four directions, reaching up to heaven and coiling down to earth; its third sense, the will to see a thing through, 気力, is the one this compound uses, and the modern word also stands for the West's spirit, esprit and Geist [2]. 統一 is to make one: a Chinese word the Book of Han uses of the Western Regions, many states and no unity, which the Japanese dictionary first cites from a scholar's handbook of 1783 and which took its philosophical sense, unity, in the Meiji translation dictionaries [3].
The text in English. The English is recent, and Eri Takase's 1999 essay sits in the middle of it.
The historical record
The philosophers, 1890 to 1897. The word was made by the men who brought German philosophy and psychology into Japanese. A commentary on the elementary-schools law of 1890 asks how, without national schooling, one could 國民精神ヲ統一シ, make the nation's spirit one [4]. The four characters together appear in 谷本富's Lectures on Scientific Pedagogy (1895), a Herbartian's survey of philosophy since Kant: Fichte held Kant's categories 精神統一の義と相容れず, incompatible with the unity of the mind; the fourth question is 精神統一の事, the unity of the mind; and Wundt made apperception 精神統一の淵源, the source of the mind's unity [5]. Two years later a translation of Höffding's psychology speaks of 精神統一テフ純然タル靈魂的思想, the purely spiritual doctrine of the unity of the soul [6], and 元良勇次郎, Japan's first professor of psychology, makes it the ground of personhood in his Ten Lectures on Psychology: 統一ハ實ニ人格ノ基礎ナリ, unity is the very basis of personality; lose it and the person dissolves, as in madness; it has a rational, ordered form and a natural, emotional one, and a lecture heading promises the physiological basis of the unity of the mind [7]. In the same year a teaching manual uses it for the Herbartian idea that the school subjects should be bound into one, with moral thought at the center [8]. Three senses in one decade — the soul as one, the curriculum as one, the nation as one — and none of them yet a person sitting still.
The practice, 1911 to 1918. The national index counts seven books using the word in the 1890s, sixteen in the 1900s, a hundred and thirty-one in the 1910s. The first book with the word in its title is 渡邊歸一's The Theory of Concentration, Clairvoyance and Clairaudience (1911) [9], from the year of the 千里眼 affair, when 福来友吉's subject 長尾郁子 said she could not 精神統一 if anyone doubted her [10]. From then the word is the name of a method. A health manual of 1913 gives a 精神統一法 for sleeplessness, count from one to ten and again [11]; a hypnotist's textbook of the same year says hypnotism is nothing but a method of fixing the subject's attention on one point, that is, a 精神統一法, and describes the breathing exercise by which 雜念去りて精神統一し, the stray thoughts leave and the mind becomes one … which is what the Zen school calls entering samādhi [12]. 岡田虎二郎's quiet-sitting swept the decade, and his recorded words refuse the word: 無念無想になろうとか、精神統一とか、精神集中なんどは一切考えてはいけません, do not think about becoming empty of thought, or about concentration, or about focus, at all [13]. A self-study book was titled Concentration Self-Taught in 1915 [14]. The Zen side noticed. A Zen primer of 1915 says Zen has become fashionable, some say for training the will, some say for 精神統一, and they have not understood what Zen means [15]; and the Engakuji master 釈宗演, lecturing in 1918, says 近頃精神統一といふ文字が流行りますが、即ち身心統一の極に達した時はさうであります, lately the phrase 精神統一 is in fashion; it is what you reach at the limit of making body and mind one, and elsewhere defines samādhi as the point where the unity of my mind is complete [16]. A ninjutsu writer of 1917 sets the ninja against what the world calls 精神統一, which pushed far enough brings on thought-photography, clairvoyance and hypnosis, and asks instead for body and mind made one together [17]. The novelist 葛西善蔵 caught the fad in Taking the Child (March 1918): a policeman friend demonstrates his own quiet-sitting method, kept up for ten years, his upper body twisting and his forehead running with sweat, and 横井はそれを「精神統一」と呼んだ … 精神統一を練習し給え, Yokoi called it concentration … you should practice concentration — it helps him spot a suspect [18]; this is the sentence the phrase dictionary cites as the word's first use. Beside all this the psychologists kept their sense: a 1918 translation of Coriat's Abnormal Psychology renders his mental synthesis, the opposite of dissociation, as 精神統一 [19].
The definition, 1926. 福来友吉, the psychologist of the 千里眼 affair, gave three lectures at 山口 in October 1925 and printed them as The Psychology of Concentration (1926). His definition: 精神統一とは、あらゆる一切の觀念が、一の目的實現に向つて共同一致して活動する狀態を云ふ, concentration is the state in which every idea works together toward the realization of one aim; it has two stages, 無念無想, the sweeping away of every stray thought until the mind is a clear mirror and still water, and 一念堅持, holding the one aim firmly in that stillness [20]. His examples are a jūjutsu master of Kumamoto, 星野九門, who told him that when a master pins something with a fingertip it is not the fingertip; the whole body's strength is gathered there, the archer of the Liezi who learns not to blink and to see a louse as a cartwheel, and the iai master 日比野雷風, whose draw is too fast for the eye [20].
The manuals, 1919 to 1939. By the 1920s the word is the plain one in the martial and ceremonial manuals. A military psychology of shooting and fencing (1919): 射擊に於ては其精神は能く統一せらるゝを要す, in shooting the mind must be well unified, and the kiai arises when the mind is unified [21]. 堀田捨次郎's illustrated kendō manual (1922) lists among the aims of kendō training 四、精神を統一せしむ, fourth, to unify the mind, and teaches 精神を竹刀の一事に集中して精神を統一し, gather the mind on the single matter of the shinai [22]. In the volume recording the 1934 tournament before the emperor, a kendō fourth-dan from Aomori gives as the third reason he won: 勝敗を全然度外視し無欲の精神により完全に精神統一が出來, having set winning and losing wholly aside, my mind came fully together through a spirit without desire, I did not stiffen, and I fought with all I had [23]. A self-defense manual of 1935 has a sixth method, 精神統一法: count the breaths to a hundred [24]. The kyūdō textbooks make it the first condition of a correct shot. 竹内尉's Kyūdō Reader (1937): if you cling to the target, 精神の統一は亂れ, the unity of the mind is disturbed, and the target itself becomes 精神統一を破る邪魔物, the obstacle that breaks concentration; the bow to the target bank is not a prayer to hit; it is a rite toward the universe, and a rite toward the universe means making one's own mind one and holding oneself in restraint [25]. The women's kyūdō guide of 1938: 完全な精神統一を必要とする … はじめて正しい射が行はれ得る, a complete concentration is required; only with concentration, composure, calm and decision is a correct shot possible [26]. The Mushanokōji tea school's procedure book (1939) writes it into the sequence: 默禮をなして居ずまひを正し精神統一, bow in silence, settle the posture, concentrate [27]. A zazen primer of 1936: with the mind settled, 精神を統一し、不動の三昧に安住する, make the mind one and rest in unmoving samādhi, and everything is zazen [28]. The temple, the sword, the bow, the tea room: the three arts Eri Takase's essay names, each with the word in print before the war.
After the war. The hypnotists kept the compound in their titles into the 1980s; a spiritualist society runs a 精神統一研修会; a 1962 newspaper profile of a weightlifting coach is headed concentration over strength; a 1977 play has a boy say he is seriously going to do 精神統一 [29]. The word is ordinary Japanese: a headband, the Japanese Wikipedia says, is worn when concentration or morale is needed [30].
What is not a source. Not Chinese: Chinese Wikisource has the four characters only in Republican-era political texts, and the national index's classical shelf has none [31]. Not Zen: the Zen masters of 1915 and 1918 name the word as a fashion from outside and fold it into their own 三昧. Not 岡田虎二郎's, who disowned it. Not a maxim with an author. The classical neighbor a reader may be thinking of is 精神一到何事か成らざらん, where the mind reaches, what can it not accomplish, from the Zhuzi yulei; a hanging scroll with its eight characters appears in a novel of 1885, and the national index finds it in over two thousand pre-war books [32]. That phrase is on the occasion shortlist; this word is the modern one.
The word in English
1976, and 1981, and 1988. Before the essay. The earliest known is Esquire for March 1976, a piece on the aikidō teacher Terry Dobson: the awake people are called seishin-toitsu … the Japanese spend a lot of time developing seishin-toitsu, through Zen, aikido, plus the other martial arts … a sense of unity, alertness — in other words, seishin-toitsu [33] — a state, and, wrongly, a name for a kind of person. Joe Hyams's Playboy's Book of Practical Self-Defense (1981) repeats the sentences [34]. Masaaki Hatsumi's Essence of Ninjutsu (1988) has it as a heading, Ninjutsu Daihi Seishintoitsu Shuyouikkan, in one-word romaji [35].
1999. Eri Takase's essay for Kampsport. Eri Takase's essay, published in January 1999, is next: my dictionary … says it means "concentration" or here "concentration of mind". While this definition is true, it is also unsatisfactory; the word is when my spirit (seishin) is gathered (touitsu), when my mind (seishin) is one (touitsu), reached through the temple gate, the grinding of the ink, the tea ceremony and the sword [36].
2003 onward. The Reiki books. Then the Reiki books, from 2003: Bronwen and Frans Stiene's Reiki Sourcebook (2003) and Japanese Art of Reiki (2005) give Seishin Toitsu: a unifying the mind meditation, the third part of the hatsurei-hō sequence; Penelope Quest (2002, 2007) concentration or meditation; Nina Paul (2005) attaining a unified mind; Nicholas Pearson (2018) the final stage of hatsurei [37]. Of fifty-six books in the Internet Archive's full text with the romaji, the great majority are Reiki.
Today. The house writes the two words as one. The standard Japanese-English dictionary's concentration of mind is the gloss Eri Takase's essay and the house share; the gloss above, the mind made one, keeps 統一's plain sense. One word, two senses in sequence. From 1890 to the 1900s, the unity of the mind: a philosopher's and psychologist's term for consciousness as one thing, the ground of personhood, the curriculum as one. From the 1910s, the gathering of the mind on one thing: a method, then a state, first in the hypnotists' and quiet-sitters' books and the 千里眼 laboratory, then, by the 1920s and 30s, in the kendō, kyūdō, tea and zazen manuals. The two senses meet in 福来's 1926 definition, every idea working as one toward one aim, and in 宗演's the limit of making body and mind one. The house's Concentration is the second sense and is right.
A reading
A word with no source is still a text with a history, and this one's is clean and short. 精神統一 was made in the 1890s by the Japanese who were making a vocabulary for German philosophy, for the unity of the mind; in the 1910s it became something one does, in the hypnotists' and quiet-sitters' manuals and the clairvoyance laboratory, a fad a Zen master named and a novelist laughed at; and by the 1920s it was the plain word in the kendō and kyūdō manuals, the tea school's procedure and the zazen primer for the gathering of the mind before an act. 福来's definition of 1926 — every idea working together toward one aim, in two stages, the mind swept clear and the one aim held — names it exactly, and the kyūdō sentence of 1937, a rite toward the universe, not a prayer to hit the target, is the ground worth reading for anyone coming to it through the martial arts.
References
- 「精神統一」, 四字熟語を知る辞典・大辞泉, at kotobank; JMdict (EDRDG) 2031630; 「精神統一」, redirect, at Japanese Wikipedia. https://kotobank.jp/word/精神統一 · https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/精神統一
- 「精神」, 精選版日本国語大辞典・大辞泉・世界大百科事典, at kotobank; 莊子, 刻意, at zh.wikisource. https://kotobank.jp/word/精神 · https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/莊子/刻意
- 「統一」, 精選版日本国語大辞典・大辞泉・字通, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/統一
- 日下部三之介, 小学校令釈義, 1890, scan 16. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/797495/1/16
- 谷本富, 科学的教育学講義, 1895, scan 60. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/808195/1/60
- ヘフヂング (石田新太郎訳), 心理学, 1897, scan 27. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/759734/1/27
- 元良勇次郎, 心理学十回講義, 1897, scan 99. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/759759/1/99
- 土井亀之進, 実験普通教授学, 1897, scan 9. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/810172/1/9
- 渡邊歸一, 精神統一千里眼千里耳の學説, 日韓書房, 1911. National Diet Library Search catalogue (not digitized).
- 「福来友吉」, at ja.wikipedia. https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/福来友吉
- 樫田十次郎, 体力精力増進法, 1913, scan 16. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/935515/1/16
- 北川潔, 科学的催眠学, 1913, scan 79. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/949389/1/79
- 「岡田式静座法」, 語録, at ja.wikipedia. https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/岡田式静座法
- 横井無隣, 内観録:精神統一自習書, 内観寮, 1915. National Diet Library Search catalogue.
- 渡辺約山, 禅学活要, 1915, scan 220. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/944036/1/220
- 釈宗演, 禅海一瀾講話, 1918, scan 101. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/943659/1/101
- 伊藤銀月, 忍術の極意, 1917, scan 85. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1088342/1/85
- 葛西善蔵, 子をつれて, 早稲田文学, March 1918, at Aozora Bunko, card 47059. https://www.aozora.gr.jp/cards/000984/files/47059_30421.html
- コーリアット (佐藤亀太郎訳), 変態心理学, 1918, scan 19; Isador Coriat, Abnormal Psychology, 1910, at Internet Archive. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/980621/1/19 · https://archive.org/details/abnormalpsycho00cori
- 福来友吉, 精神統一の心理, 日本心霊学会, 1926, scan 71. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/981789/1/71
- 下沢瑞世 (編), 射撃と剣術並に航空術の心理, 兵事雑誌社, 1919, scan 14. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/942248/1/14
- 堀田捨次郎, 図解剣道教範, 1922, scan 12. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/965095/1/12
- 昭和天覧試合, 1934, scan 307. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1232699/1/307
- 武道極意護身術秘伝, 1935, scan 130. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1025860/1/130
- 竹内尉, 弓道読本, 1937, scan 44. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1052433/1/44
- 女子弓道指針, 1938, scan 7. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1054810/1/7
- 千家官休庵流点前, 1939, scan 78. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1239799/1/78
- 中根環堂, 坐禅の極意, 1936, scan 20. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1036952/1/20
- National Diet Library Search catalogue, postwar titles carrying 精神統一法 (小菅一男 1957; 世和玄次 1974) and the phrase in other titles.
- 「鉢巻」・「日本心霊科学協会」, at ja.wikipedia. https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/鉢巻
- zh.wikisource, search for 精神統一 (11 hits, all Republican-era). https://zh.wikisource.org
- 「精神一到何事か成らざらん」, at kotobank (朱子語類, and 坪内逍遙, 1885). https://kotobank.jp/word/精神一到何事か成らざらん
- Esquire, vol. 85, no. 3, March 1976, at Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/esquire_1976-03_85_3
- Joe Hyams, Playboy's Book of Practical Self-Defense, Playboy Press, 1981, at Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/playboysbookofpr00hyam
- Masaaki Hatsumi, Essence of Ninjutsu: The Nine Traditions, Contemporary Books, 1988, at Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/essenceofninjuts00hats
- Eri Takase, "Seishintouitsu", Kampsport, January 1999, at takase.com Library. https://takase.com/library/seishintouitsu-concentration-of-mind/
- Bronwen and Frans Stiene, The Reiki Sourcebook, O Books, 2003, and The Japanese Art of Reiki, 2005; Penelope Quest, Reiki for Life, 2002, and The Basics of Reiki, 2007; Nina Paul, Reiki for Dummies, 2005; Nicholas Pearson, Foundations of Reiki Ryōhō, 2018, at Internet Archive. https://archive.org/details/reikisourcebook0000stie
