Fine Japanese Calligraphy

The Art of Master Japanese Calligrapher Eri Takase

希望は最大の宝 kibō wa saidai no takara Hope is our greatest treasure

希望は最大の宝 (kibō wa saidai no takara) is plain modern Japanese, sold by the house as its Japanese for hope is our greatest treasure. No book or magazine in the National Diet Library's full-text index carries it. This study sets out its relatives in both languages, from a 万葉集 poem to Hazlitt and a Japanese Smiles, none of them a source.

Abstract

希望は最大の宝, kibō wa saidai no takara, hope is the greatest treasure, is grammatical modern Japanese, and the house sells it as the Japanese for an English line, hope is our greatest treasure; no book or magazine in the National Diet Library's full-text index carries it, which is a fact about the index, not about where the line came from. Its thought has relatives in both languages: in English, William Hazlitt's maxim Hope is the best possession (1823) and hope is the greatest treasure mankind has in a children's newspaper of 1929; in Japanese, a 1948 translation of Vauvenargues, whose maxim calls hope the most useful or the most pernicious of goods, a 1968 teachers' magazine with 希望こそ最大の宝物, and, nearest in wording, 「希望」は最大の財産である, hope is the greatest asset, a chapter heading in Japanese adaptations of Samuel Smiles from 1984. A treasure set above all others is old in Japanese: the dictionary's first citation for 宝 is a 万葉集 poem, in a set its colophon dates to 728, asking what treasure surpasses a child. All of these are family resemblances; none is a source.

Overview

The sense. Standard Japanese: a maxim in the plainest possible form, subject, wa, predicate.

The words. 希望, hope, has two lives in the dictionary. Read kemō, the older 呉音 reading, its first citation is the 往生要集 of 984–985, written 悕望, and then the 沙石集 of 1283, まして布施の希望(ケマウ)は名利の為也; the dictionary notes that kemō was the usual reading until near the end of the Edo period. Read kibō, its first citations are an 1872 newspaper and an 1875 translation, both written with the synonym 冀望, and the dictionary judges that kibō had become the usual reading by about 1887 (思われる, it seems): Hepburn's dictionary of 1886 gives only キボウ. The dictionary's two senses are the two the maxim uses: the wish for a thing to come true, and 将来への明るい見通し, a bright outlook on the future [1]. 最大 saidai, greatest, is cited from the 宝物集 of about 1179 [2]. 宝 takara, treasure, has as its first citation a poem in the 万葉集, 銀も金も玉も何せむにまされる多可良子にしかめやも, silver, gold, jewels, what are they to me; what treasure surpasses a child; the dictionary cites it as 万葉集 5.803 and does not name the poet [3]. The poem is the envoy to 子等を思ふ歌, and the set it belongs to closes with the line 神亀五年七月の二十一日、嘉摩の郡にて撰定ぶ。筑前国守山上憶良: chosen in Kama district on the twenty-first day of the seventh month of 728, by Yamanoue no Okura, governor of Chikuzen [4].

The text in English. Hope and 希望 match in both senses, the wish and the outlook [5].

The historical record

No witness. 希望は最大の宝 as written returns nothing from the National Diet Library's full-text index, which reads the Library's digitized books and magazines of every access tier, the ones served only in Japan as well as the public-domain ones [6]. The Library's public-domain books alone return nothing either [7].

The nearest wordings in Japanese. Two items in the same index come close before 1970. One is a 1948 translation of the French moralist Vauvenargues, whose maxim 739 reads, as translated, 希望は寶の中での最も有益… [8]; the French is L'espérance est le plus utile ou le plus pernicieux des biens, hope is the most useful or the most pernicious of goods [9]. The other is a 1968 number of 小六教育技術, a magazine for teachers of the sixth grade, which says of a great king (大王) that he 希望こそ最大の宝物と考え、前へ前へ進んだ, took hope for the greatest treasure, and pressed ever forward [10]; it is a story told of a king, not a maxim. Later wordings come nearer in form. 「希望」は最大の財産である, hope is the greatest asset, is a chapter heading in two Japanese adaptations of Samuel Smiles published by 三笠書房, 『向上心 続』 (1984) and 『自己実現の方法』 (1989); a 1995 essay has 希望は、最大の財産であるとしている, holds that hope is the greatest asset, and a 1997 handbook 人生の目的や希望は、最大の財産です [11]. An English line of Smiles's behind the heading was not found here: hope is the greatest wealth and hope is the greatest possession return nothing of his from the Internet Archive's full text. 希望は人生の宝, hope is life's treasure, is the motto of the yūzen artist 森口華弘 in a 1996 collection of mottoes, and the heading of a 1992 essay page in PHP [12]. All of these are snippet views.

In English. The sold English line, hope is our greatest treasure, returns nothing from the Internet Archive's full-text index [13]. Without the our it is older. The tenth-birthday editorial of The Children's Newspaper, 23 March 1929, signed A. M., has To be born with hope is to be born rich, for hope is the greatest treasure mankind has [14]. And a maxim of the same thought, older than either, has an author: William Hazlitt's Characteristics (1823), number XXXIV, Hope is the best possession. None are completely wretched but those who are without hope; and few are reduced so low as that [15].

What is not a source. No witness joins any of these to the Japanese maxim. The 万葉集 poem, the French maxim, the Smiles heading and the English lines are resemblances. The house sells 希望は最大の宝 as its Japanese for hope is our greatest treasure; which of the two was written first, no printed witness says.

Today. The Japanese has no word for the English line's our: Japanese needs no possessor, so the line speaks for whoever reads it.

A reading

Honest modern Japanese, and it stands as that. What it shares with its relatives is a ranking, not a descent. Okura asked what treasure surpasses a child, a question with its answer inside it; the maxim states its answer flatly, subject, wa, predicate. Hazlitt called hope the best possession because the one who keeps it is never completely wretched, and the 1929 editorial because it lifts us up; the maxim gives no reason at all, which is the plainest form a claim like this can take.

References

  1. 「希望」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/希望
  2. 「最大」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/最大
  3. 「宝」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/宝
  4. 『万葉集』巻第五, 鹿持雅澄 訓訂, at Wikisource: poem 0803 and the colophon after 0805. https://ja.wikisource.org/wiki/万葉集_(鹿持雅澄訓訂)/巻第五
  5. JMdict (EDRDG), 「希望」, at jisho. https://jisho.org/word/希望
  6. National Diet Library Digital Collections, full-text search on 希望は最大の宝, all access tiers, 0 items. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/search/searchResult?keyword=希望は最大の宝&fulltext=true
  7. National Diet Library, next-generation full-text search (the public-domain books), on 希望は最大の宝, 0 books. https://lab.ndl.go.jp/dl/api/book/search?searchfield=contentonly&keyword=希望は最大の宝
  8. ヴオオヴナルグ 著, 大塚幸男 訳『情熱の倫理 : ヴオオヴナルグ随想録』, 養徳社, 1948, scan 110, maxim 七三九, snippet view, National Diet Library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1132648
  9. Réflexions et maximes, 739, in Œuvres de Vauvenargues (1857), at Wikisource. https://fr.wikisource.org/wiki/Page:Œuvres_de_Vauvenargues_(1857).djvu/530
  10. 『小六教育技術』20(12), 小学館, February 1968, scan 32, snippet view, National Diet Library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/search/searchResult?keyword=希望こそ最大の宝&fulltext=true
  11. National Diet Library Digital Collections, full-text search on 希望は最大の財産, all access tiers, 4 items: サミュエル・スマイルズ 著『向上心 続』, 三笠書房, 1984, scan 4; 『自己実現の方法』, 三笠書房, 1989, scan 4; 『東と西』 13, 亜細亜大学言語・文化研究所, 1995, scan 13; 『老いと暮らしの実用百科』, 時事通信社, 1997, scan 19; snippet views. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/search/searchResult?keyword=希望は最大の財産&fulltext=true
  12. National Diet Library Digital Collections, full-text search on 希望は人生の宝, all access tiers: PHP研究所 編『ことばの贈り物 : 達人たちの座右の銘203』, PHP研究所, 1996, scan 100; PHP 530, July 1992, scan 11; snippet views. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/search/searchResult?keyword=希望は人生の宝&fulltext=true
  13. Internet Archive full-text search on "hope is our greatest treasure", 0 results. https://archive.org/search?query=%22hope+is+our+greatest+treasure%22&sin=TXT
  14. The Children's Newspaper, 23 March 1929, p. 6, "We Are Ten". https://archive.org/details/The_Childrens_Newspaper_0522_1929-03-23
  15. William Hazlitt, Characteristics: In the Manner of Rochefoucault's Maxims, second edition, London: J. Templeman, 1837, p. 13, no. XXXIV (first published 1823). https://archive.org/details/characteristicsi00hazl

Authors