Fine Japanese Calligraphy

The Art of Master Japanese Calligrapher Eri Takase

決して降伏しない kesshite kōfuku shinai Never Surrender

決して降伏しない (kesshite kōfuku shinai), never surrender, is a plain Japanese sentence of resolve. It has rendered Churchill's we shall never surrender since the war years, and it is older than his speech. This study follows the English cry from a Boston song of 1768, and the Japanese from translations and a lecture of 1904.

Abstract

決して降伏しない, kesshite kōfuku shinai, never surrender, is a plain Japanese sentence of resolve, older in Japanese than Churchill's we shall never surrender of 4 June 1940, which it has rendered since the war years. The English cry is older still: a Boston song of 1768, Napoleon's Guard at Waterloo in an English account of 1816, and Travis at the Alamo in 1836. The Japanese came from two directions: translations of Western lives gave Garibaldi in 1892 and General Taylor in 1910 the written-style 決して降服せず and 決して降伏せず, a crib for an English reader glossed He never would give in as 決シテ降服シナイ in 1910, and Hugo's résolus à ne jamais nous rendre became 決して降伏しない in 1921; while a lecture of March 1904, in the first weeks of the war with Russia, vowed of Japan 決して降服はしない. By 1913 a handbook of reading aloud used 決して決して、降伏しない to teach a repeated phrase.

Overview

The sense. A resolution with no subject: never surrender. It is a sentence, not a set phrase.

The words. 降伏 kōfuku, surrender: 戦いに負けたことを認めて、相手に従うこと, to admit defeat and submit, the word of 無条件降伏, unconditional surrender. The 日本国語大辞典 enters it under both of its spellings, 降伏 and 降服, and its first example of the sense is from the 続日本紀 for the year 740, where it is written 降服 [1]. 決して kesshite with a negative is never, by no means [2].

The text in English. Never surrender is word for word: 決して, never; 降伏しない, do not surrender. The Japanese, like the English, names no one who refuses.

The historical record

1768 to 1836. The English cry. In the Boston Gazette of 3 October 1768 a song of liberty for Massachusetts has the sons of the brave who Will never ſurrender, But ſwear to defend her, in the text layer of the digitized page [3]. An English translation of 1816 of a French account of Waterloo gives the Guard's answer, when it was summoned to surrender, as The guard never surrender, they die [4]. From the Alamo, on 24 February 1836, William Barret Travis wrote: I shall never surrender or retreat [5].

1892 and 1910. The written style, in translation. The idea entered Japanese print in the written style, in translations of Western lives. In 1892 高橋光威's Japanese of Bolton, 貧児立身伝, lives of poor boys who rose, has Garibaldi, mounted before his men, declare ベニス(地名)トガリバルヂートハ決シテ降服セズ, Venice and Garibaldi never surrender [6]. In 1910 竹村修's Japanese of Marden, 立志論, has General Taylor, surrounded at Buena Vista and invited to surrender, answer 『テーラー將軍は決して降伏せず』, General Taylor never surrenders [7].

1904. A Japanese vow. The spoken sentence is in print by March 1904, in the first weeks of the war with Russia, in a lecture printed in 倉敷日曜講演 and reprinted in the magazine 新公論 in April: in such a case we shall first stab to death our own wives and children, and then, as long as life lasts, 刀折れ、馬斃れ、身は戰塲の土と化する迄も決して降服はしない, swords broken, horses fallen, until our bodies become the earth of the battlefield, we will never surrender; when the Japanese Empire falls, it says, the Japanese people fall with it [8]. The は makes it emphatic. It is Japanese prose about Japan's own war, owing nothing to a translation.

1910. The plain sentence, from English. The plain form, with no は, is in print by July 1910, in a crib for an English reader: under the line He never would give in it gives 彼ハ決シテ降服シナイ, he never surrenders [9]. The Japanese sentence enters here as the gloss of an English one.

1913. A sentence to read aloud. In 1913 日下部重太郎's handbook of reading Japanese aloud, 国文朗読法, teaches that repeated words are read faster, with three examples: ○高い高い山。○春が來た、春が來た。○決して決して、降伏しない。 [10]. By then the sentence was plain enough to stand beside a high, high mountain and spring has come.

1917 and 1921. Translation. A translated war book of 1917 has it of Germany: 强情我慢の彼れは、決して降伏しないかも知れぬ, stubborn as he is, he may never surrender [11]. In 1921 the Japanese Hugo has the exiles standing 決して降伏しない決心で, resolved never to surrender, in the breach called exile [12]. Hugo said it at the grave of his fellow exile Hennett de Kesler, on Guernsey, on 7 April 1870: nous sommes là, résolus à ne jamais nous rendre, debout sur cette grande brèche qu'on appelle l'exil [13]. The Japanese of 1921 renders a French never surrender.

1940. Churchill. On 4 June 1940, after Dunkirk, Churchill's last sentence to the Commons runs we shall fight on the beaches … we shall fight in the hills; we shall never surrender, and goes on to the Empire beyond the seas and the New World that steps forth to the rescue and the liberation of the old [14]. In May 1944 a Japanese wartime weekly quoted the passage to call it empty bravado, ending われわれは決して降伏しない [15], and a 1960 Japanese life of Churchill renders the line 決して降伏しないであろう [16].

A reading

The sentence is older in Japanese than the speech that made it famous in English, and it came from two directions at once. Translation brought the refusals of Garibaldi and an American general, an English schoolbook's He never would give in, and Hugo's exiles; and in 1904 a lecturer at war said it of Japan in a sentence of its own, with a vow to die on the field behind it. By 1913 a teacher could set it beside spring has come as a sentence any child could say. What Churchill's line found in Japanese was a sentence already worn smooth, and already spoken by Japan of itself.

Notes

References

  1. 「降伏」, at kotobank: 精選版 日本国語大辞典, with the 初出 続日本紀 天平12年 (740); デジタル大辞泉. https://kotobank.jp/word/降伏-63085
  2. 「決して」, at kotobank: 精選版 日本国語大辞典. https://kotobank.jp/word/決して-489955
  3. The Boston Gazette, and Country Journal, 3 October 1768, a song of liberty for Massachusetts, the text layer of the digitized page. https://archive.org/details/per_boston-gazette_the-boston-gazette-and-country-journal_1768-10-03_2_705
  4. François-Thomas Delbare, French Account of the Last Campaign of Buonaparte, 1816, the text layer. https://archive.org/details/10409645bsb
  5. William Barret Travis, letter "To the People of Texas & all Americans in the world", 24 February 1836, full text at the Texas State Library and Archives Commission. https://www.tsl.texas.gov/treasures/republic/alamo/travis-full-text.html
  6. ボルトン (tr. 高橋光威), 貧児立身伝, 新進堂, 1892, p. 47 and the next page. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/777321/1/27
  7. マーデン (tr. 竹村修), 立志論, 内外出版協会, 1910, scan 57. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/758506/1/57
  8. 倉敷日曜講演, March 1904; 新公論, 15 April 1904, the same passage; both from the index's excerpts, not open outside the library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/12717245 · https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/11005391
  9. 浅田氏英語読本字解, 春畝堂, July 1910, scan 114. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/870624/1/114
  10. 日下部重太郎, 国文朗読法, 丁未出版社, 1913, p. 116. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/951522/1/65
  11. ピエール・ノーソン (tr. 藤田進一郎), 兇独, 1917, from the index's excerpt; not open outside the library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/955900
  12. ユーゴー全集刊行会 編, ユーゴー全集, ユーゴー全集刊行会 (冬夏社内), 1921, p. 438. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1718764/1/440
  13. Victor Hugo, Actes et paroles, Pendant l'exil, "Hennett de Kesler" (7 April 1870), Paris: Nelson, p. 498. https://archive.org/details/actesetparoles02hugouoft
  14. Winston Churchill, "We Shall Fight on the Beaches" (4 June 1940), International Churchill Society. https://winstonchurchill.org/resources/speeches/1940-1946-churchill-in-war-and-peace/we-shall-fight-on-the-beaches/
  15. 同盟世界週報, 同盟通信社, May 1944, from the index's excerpt; not open outside the library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1399412
  16. 山上正太郎, ウィンストン・チャーチル : 二つの世界戦争, 誠文堂新光社, 1960, from the index's excerpt; not open outside the library. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2986377

Authors