一期一会 ichigo ichie Each Moment Only Once
This is a philological study of the Japanese four-character word 一期一会 (ichigo ichie). It spans from a fourteenth-century idiom in the war tales, through Rikyū's disciple's sentence on the etiquette of a single tea, to a nineteenth-century lord's four-character coinage that print did not take up for seventy years, and examines why 一期 means a lifetime, not "once in a lifetime."
Abstract
一期一会, one lifetime, one meeting, is a four-character word coined by Ii Naosuke 井伊直弼 in the preface to his tea manual 茶湯一会集, about 1845, compressing a sixteenth-century sentence from his tradition's own literature, 山上宗二記, into four characters. The underlying idiom, once in a lifetime, is older still, ordinary Japanese in the fourteenth-century war tales. Print did not take up Ii's word for seventy years; the school readers of the 1920s fixed both its reading and its currency, and the twentieth century widened it past tea to any meeting that happens once. The tradition that credits the idea to Sen no Rikyū rests on his disciple's book, in a section headed as another master's teaching, not on a sentence of Rikyū's own. English has carried the word since the 1970s, most often as one time, one meeting, and Ii's preface has been translated twice.
Overview
The sense. Three layers, three ages. The medieval phrase means once in a lifetime and nothing more. Yamanoue Sōji 山上宗二's sentence makes it a discipline of attention for the length of one tea. Ii's word makes the discipline mutual, host and guest each knowing the day will not return, and adds the host alone at the hearth afterward. The twentieth century widened it past tea to any meeting that happens once, and the dictionaries now carry both.
The words. 一期, ichigo, is one lifetime, from birth to death, a Buddhist term: Hepburn's dictionary of 1872 has ICHI-GO 一期 n. Whole life [1], and a Buddhist dictionary of 1933 quotes Rennyo 蓮如's まぼろしの如くなる一期なり, a lifetime like an illusion [2]. It does not mean once in a lifetime; that is the sense of the whole idiom, or of the older phrase 一期に一度. 一会, ichie, is one meeting, one gathering, and in tea one 茶会. The reading was not always settled: school glosses of the late 1920s give イチゴイチヱ, イチゴイックワイ and イチゴイツクワイ, because 会 has two readings [3]; the 1936 edition of the coiner's own book prints いちごいちゑ beside the characters [4], and every dictionary since reads ichie. Every witness before 1946 writes 會.
The proverb in English. Okakura's Book of Tea (1906) does not have the word; its nearest thought is Rikyū's last tea [5]. No bilingual dictionary from Hepburn 1872 to 1948 has it [1], and no English proverb collection from Buchanan 1965 to Galef 2012 does. The word reached English through the budō and tea books of the 1970s and after: Draeger's one period, one encounter (1973) [6], Sen Sōshitsu's one time, one meeting (1979) [7], which Varley and Kumakura's Tea in Japan (1989) fixed as the standard rendering with a translation of Ii's preface [8], and a second translation in Hirota's Wind in the Pines (1995) [9]; the calligraphy books give One Meeting, One Life (Reed 1989) [10] and One Lifetime One Meeting (Sato 2013) [11]. JMdict: once-in-a-lifetime encounter; uniquely precious experience; one lifetime, one meeting [12]. The English Wikipedia lists for this time only, once in a lifetime, one time, one meeting [13].
The historical record
Fourteenth century. 一期に一度 in the war tales. Before there was a tea room the phrase once in a lifetime was ordinary Japanese: in the 曽我物語 a warrior pleads その上一期に一度の大事をこそと存じ候うて, knowing this to be the one great matter of a lifetime; in the 義経記 a crowd calls a spectacle 一期に一度の大事 [14].
1588. 山上宗二記, the tea record of Rikyū's disciple, the section on the guest's conduct. 常の茶湯なりとも路地へはゐるから立迄一期に一度の参会の様に亭主を … 畏るべき也, even at an ordinary tea, from entering the roji until you leave, hold the host in awe as if it were the one gathering of a lifetime. The medieval phrase applied to the walk from the garden gate to the tea room. In a 1902 typeset the passage is headed as what Takeno Jōō 紹鷗 taught, with Rikyū's dislikes noted beside it; it is not Rikyū's sentence at any known address [15][16].
About 1845. Ii Naosuke, 茶湯一会集, the preface. The lord of Hikone, who would be killed at the Sakurada Gate in 1860, coins the word and glosses it in one sentence: 抑茶湯の交會は、一期一會といひて、たとへば幾度おなじ主客交會するとも、今日の會にふたゝびかへらざる事を思へば、實に我一世一度の會なり, the meeting of host and guests at tea is called one lifetime, one meeting: however many times the same host and guests may meet, today's gathering will not come again, and it is truly the one meeting of my life. So the host spares nothing, and the guest, knowing the same, slights nothing the host devised. 是を一期一會といふ, this is what is called ichigo ichie. Later in the book comes 獨座觀念: after the guests leave, the host does not clear up but returns to the hearth, sits alone, and considers that today's one meeting is over and will not return [4].
1889. Ōtsuki Fumihiko 大槻文彦, 言海. The everyday phrase the lord glossed his coinage with: 一世一代〔一世一度ノ訛カ〕生涯ノ中ニテ此度ヲ限リトスルコト, once in a lifetime [17].
1910. Fujii Otoo 藤井乙男, 諺語大辞典. The word is not there. The イチゴ run has 一期末代 and no 一期一會; nor is the word in any of nineteen bilingual and proverb dictionaries from 1872 to 1948 [18].
1917. 釈悟庵, 禅林清話. The first book in the public-domain corpus to print the four characters, seventy years after they were coined: 茶の湯の極致は一期一會に獨座觀念とにあるのぢや, the height of tea lies in ichigo ichie and in sitting alone in contemplation, grounded in the Buddhist instant that arises and perishes [19].
1920 to 1923. The word spreads. A tea writer sets it beside the Lotus Sutra's 難値難遇, hard to meet, hard to encounter (奥田正造, 茶味, 1920) [20]; a moral lecturer says 井伊大老が一期一會と云つたのは、そこのことである (Anesaki Masaharu 姉崎正治, 1920) [21]; a playwright gives it to a Zen priest bidding Ii farewell before the Sakurada Gate: 茶の湯も一期一會なら、お互さまも一期一會、逢へば別れる、別れゝば逢ふ (Nakamura Kichizō 中村吉蔵, 1920) [22]; and Sōma Gyofū 相馬御風 sets it beside Bashō's saying that yesterday's hokku is today's death poem (1923) [23].
1927 to 1934. The school readers. The word enters the readers with a gloss, which is how a word becomes everyone's: 一生に一たび相會ふこと (1927), 一生涯にたつた一度の會といふ意。一期は人間の一生涯 (1928). The count of public-domain books carrying it, by five-year span: one in 1915 to 1919, seven in 1920 to 1924, nine, nine, thirty-three in 1935 to 1939, forty-one in 1940 to 1944 [3].
What is not a source. Sen no Rikyū. The tradition holds that the concept dates to him; the earliest attestation is his disciple's book, in a section headed as another master's teaching, and the four characters are a lord's, written two and a half centuries after Rikyū's death. Rikyū's name may stand as the tradition; it is not a fact of the sources. The 南方録, which the 日本大百科全書 sets between Sōji and Ii with the phrase 一座一会, is not in the digital library. 一世一度 and 一世一代 are the everyday kin; 難値難遇 is the sutra phrase a tea writer paired with it in 1920 [20].
The dictionaries today. 精選版日本国語大辞典: 一生に一度会うこと。また、一生に一度限りであること, with Ii's preface as first citation. デジタル大辞泉: the tea sense first, then 転じて一生に一度しかない出会い. 共同通信's entry says the idea 千利休の考えといわれている, is said to be Rikyū's, which is the tradition, not a source [24].
The proverb in English
1973. Draeger, Classical Budo, Weatherhill. The earliest English witness known is a budō book, not a tea book: Each session with his master is precious. It is ichi-go ichi-e, "one period, one encounter," each session an opportunity to share a training experience with his master that comes only once [6].
1979. Sen Sōshitsu, Tea Life, Tea Mind, Weatherhill, page 41. The grand master of Urasenke, writing in English: In Tea the expression ichigo ichie is frequently heard. It means "one time, one meeting." Each tea gathering is an opportunity for an experience that will never occur again in one's life; and Rikyū's last scroll for the priest Kokei as the spirit of ichigo ichie [7]. One time, one meeting is the rendering the tea books have kept since.
1983. Katō, A History of Japanese Literature, volume two, Macmillan, page 129. For the tea man, the ideal of performing each ceremony as if it were the only and most important one in his life (ichigo ichie), set beside Sei Shōnagon and the Genroku hedonists as three forms of one aesthetic [25].
1989. Paul Varley and Kumakura Isao, editors, Tea in Japan: Essays on the History of Chanoyu, University of Hawaii Press, pages 28 and 187. An English translation of Ii's preface, the earliest known: Great attention should be given to a tea gathering, which we can speak of as "one time, one meeting" (ichigo, ichie). Even though the host and guests may see each other often socially, one day's gathering can never be repeated exactly. Viewed this way, the meeting is indeed a once-in-a-lifetime occasion … This is what is meant by "one time, one meeting." The chapter then says the term appeared first in Yamanoue Sōji Ki. But it was given its classical definition by Ii Naosuke; the 宗二記 leaf reads 一期に一度, the phrase and not the four characters, so the first half of that sentence is the tradition and the second half is what the leaves show. Page 28 heads a section One Time, One Meeting (Ichigo, Ichie) [8].
1989. Reed, Shodo, Japan Publications, page 183. Number 25 of the book's model phrases: Ichi-go Ichi-e. One Meeting, One Life. Samurai warriors readied themselves for battle by shedding their swords and partaking of the Tea Ceremony [10].
1995. Hirota, Wind in the Pines, Asian Humanities Press, pages 179 and 291. A second translation of the preface, under the heading Preface by Ii Naosuke: The gathering in chanoyu is spoken of as "a single encounter in a lifetime" (ichigo ichie). Thus, although the same host and guests may come together a number of times, when one considers that one cannot return again to the gathering of this very day, one realizes it indeed occurs but once in one's life; and, on renga, the attitude of host and guest, "In this lifetime, this single encounter" (ichigo ichie) [9].
1996 to 2005. The tea and Zen books. Tanahashi, on calligraphy for the tea alcove: "ichigo ichie," which means "an unprecedented, unrepeatable encounter" (1996) [26]; Tanaka: "ichi go ichi e," or "one chance in one's lifetime" (1998) [27]; Plutschow, on Hōunsai: Ichigo ichie (one time, one meeting) is one of the tea teachings inspired by Zen. It was the daimyo Ii Naosuke (1815–60) who, in his work entitled Chanoyu Ichie Shū, stressed this principle in tea for the first time, with Hōunsai's own gloss, does not simply refer to a chance or good opportunity (2001) [28]; Garrison's idiom dictionary: "in one lifetime, one meeting," a once-in-a-lifetime meeting (2002) [29]; Sasaki's almanac opens with Ichigo ichie: every encounter is once in a lifetime (2005) [30].
2011 to 2024. The word as a commonplace. The 2011 foreword to Sadler's Cha-no-yu notes that Sadler's story of Ii makes no mention that it was he who popularized the phrase "ichigo ichie" in the world of tea [31]; Sato's calligraphy manual sets it among the four-character zengo, Ichi Go Ichi E ("One Lifetime One Meeting") … one of the most popular sayings for display in the tokonoma (2013) [11]; Mogi's Ikigai carries the legend, Rikyū is the most likely originator of this important idea (2017) [32]; an aesthetics essay has literally a once-in-a-lifetime event (2018) [33]; Fitzsimons's Bashō, in a note, The phrase ichigo ichie (literally, "one time, one meeting") is still a commonplace in Japan (2022) [34]; Waddell's Hakuin, the well-known phrase ichigo ichie—"one time, one meeting"—that is, treasure each meeting; it will never come again (2024) [35].
Today. JMdict: once-in-a-lifetime encounter; uniquely precious experience; one lifetime, one meeting [12]. The house title, Each Moment Only Once, is a paraphrase in the once in a lifetime line that Sasaki and Nguyen also use, fair as English; word for word the text says one lifetime, one meeting, and the tea books' one time, one meeting keeps both nouns. What a rendering must keep is that 一期 is a lifetime and 一会 a meeting, and that the word was made for two people in a small room, not for a moment in general.
A reading
A phrase from the war tales, Rikyū's school applying it to the walk from the garden gate to the tea room, and Ii Naosuke, who would die at the Sakurada Gate, folding the sentence into four characters in his tea manual and describing what the host does after the guests leave, alone at the hearth with one kettle. The word was his, print did not take it up for seventy years, and the schoolbooks of the 1920s still argued its reading.
References
- J. C. Hepburn, 『和英語林集成』, 2nd ed., American Presbyterian Mission Press, 1872, ICHI-GO 一期. National Diet Library pid 993689, scan 94. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/993689/1/94
- 東方仏教協会 編『仏教文化辞典』, 1933. National Diet Library pid 1092539, scan 22. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1092539/1/22
- The school apparatus: 垣内松三編『国文鑒 教授参考書』, 文学社, 1927; 『新定国文読本参考書』巻五, 1928; 『現代国語読本 教授参考書』, 東京開成館, 1929; 『国文鑒』, 1934. National Diet Library pid 1266817, scan 151. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1266817/1/151
- 井伊宗観『茶湯一會集』, 奥田正造編, 法母庵, 1936, p. 1. National Diet Library pid 1185983, scan 6. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1185983/1/6
- Kakuzō Okakura, The Book of Tea, 1906, at archive.org. https://archive.org/download/bookoftea00okakrich/bookoftea00okakrich_djvu.txt
- Draeger, Classical Budo, Weatherhill, 1973.
- Sen Sōshitsu, Tea Life, Tea Mind, Weatherhill, 1979, p. 41.
- Paul Varley and Kumakura Isao, editors, Tea in Japan: Essays on the History of Chanoyu, University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu, 1989, pp. 28 and 187.
- Hirota, Wind in the Pines, Asian Humanities Press, 1995, pp. 179 and 291.
- Reed, Shodo, Japan Publications, 1989, p. 183, no. 25.
- Sato, Shodo: The Quiet Art of Japanese Zen Calligraphy, Tuttle, 2013, p. 84.
- JMdict, 「一期一会」, at gokanji. https://new.gokanji.com/word/一期一会
- 「Ichi-go ichi-e」, English Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ichi-go_ichi-e
- 大町桂月校『曽我物語』, 1911; 『有朋堂文庫』義経記, 1913. National Diet Library pid 877589, scan 60. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/877589/1/60
- 『宗二之記』(山上宗二), manuscript, undated. National Diet Library pid 2538367, canvas 46. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2538367
- 『日本社会事彙』, 経済雑誌社, 1902, entry 茶の湯. National Diet Library pid 1805636, scan 376. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1805636/1/376
- 大槻文彦『言海』, 1889. National Diet Library pid 992954, scan 105. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/992954/1/105
- 藤井乙男編『諺語大辞典』, 有朋堂, 1910. National Diet Library pid 862766, scan 50. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/862766/1/50
- 釈悟庵編『禅林清話 力ある修養』, 文瑛書院, 1917. National Diet Library pid 944170, scan 98. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/944170/1/98
- 奥田正造『茶味』, 成蹊学園出版部, 1920. National Diet Library pid 937840, scan 51. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/937840/1/51
- 姉崎正治『光あれ』, 1920. National Diet Library pid 961752, scan 66. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/961752/1/66
- 中村吉蔵『井伊大老の死 史劇』, 天佑社, 1920. National Diet Library pid 962957, scan 36. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/962957/1/36
- 相馬御風『愚庵和尚 その他』, 春陽堂, 1923, 生の寂味. National Diet Library pid 977969, scan 43. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/977969/1/43
- 「一期一会」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版 日本国語大辞典・共同通信, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/一期一会
- Katō, A History of Japanese Literature, volume two, Macmillan, 1983, p. 129.
- Tanahashi, Endless Vow, Shambhala, 1996, p. 25.
- Tanaka, The Tea Ceremony, Kodansha International, 1998, p. 170.
- Plutschow, The Grand Tea Master, Weatherhill, 2001, the chapter on Hōunsai's tea and Zen, and p. 87.
- Garrison, Kodansha's Dictionary of Basic Japanese Idioms, Kodansha International, 2002, p. 122.
- Sasaki, Chado, the Way of Tea: Almanac, Tuttle, 2005, foreword.
- Sadler, The Japanese Tea Ceremony: Cha-no-yu, Tuttle, 2011 edition, the foreword.
- Mogi, The Little Book of Ikigai, Quercus, 2017.
- Nguyen, ed., New Essays in Japanese Aesthetics, Lexington Books, 2018.
- Fitzsimons, Bashō: The Complete Haiku, University of California Press, 2022, p. 275, note to 744.
- Waddell, Hakuin's Song of Zazen, Shambhala, 2024.
