Fine Japanese Calligraphy

The Art of Master Japanese Calligrapher Eri Takase

0

守護天使 shugo tenshi Guardian Angel

This is a philological study of the Japanese word 守護天使 (shugo tenshi), guardian angel. It spans the record from a doctrine resting on two Bible verses the Meiji Protestant translation does not carry, through two rival Japanese renderings the Catholic and Orthodox missions coined a decade apart, to a compound that became the ordinary Japanese word by 1929, and it examines how the Orthodox Church's four solid characters outlived the Catholic Church's own particle-marked phrase in general use.

守護天使 · shugo tenshi · Guardian Angel — the angel who guards one person; the Japanese Orthodox Church's word, printed with its reading in 1905, for a doctrine the Catholic catechism of 1896 had already written as 守護の天使; today the ordinary Japanese word

Abstract

守護天使, shugo tenshi, is a church's word: the Japanese Orthodox Church printed it with this reading in 1905, and it has since become the everyday Japanese word for the angel assigned to guard a person. The Catholic Church in Japan writes the same idea with a particle, 守護の天使, a decade earlier in its own 1896 catechism, and the Meiji Protestant Bible on which most Japanese would have met the doctrine carries neither word at either of the two verses it rests on. By 1929 an English-Japanese dictionary gave the Orthodox compound as the equivalent of guardian angel, and it is that line the modern dictionaries and Wikipedia descend from.

Overview

The sense. Devotional and plain; the angel of a child's prayer. One: the angel assigned to guard a person.

The words. Shugo is guarding, and its oldest Japanese sense already holds the guardian: the dictionary's first meaning is to guard; a guard; also a guardian god, with a ninth-century tale of miracles as the first witness, he knew it was heaven's guarding [1]. A Japanese reader meets the word first as a title, because its second sense is the provincial constable the shogunate appointed from 1185, and the Christian missionaries of 1600 used it for Pontius Pilate as governor [1]. A line of Han Yu gives the sense this compound wants: spirits guard it and forbid ill fortune [2]. Protect; guard; safeguard, the usual glosses, are right. Tenshi is heaven's envoy, the Chinese emperor's messenger for two thousand years, the messenger of hell in a diary of 1223, and angel only from Fukuzawa in 1866 and the Meiji Bible, which read the two characters as ten no tsukai [3]. The Catholic catechism of 1896 read them another way, amatsukai, the native word for the same thing. The dictionaries' neighbors mark the edges: 守護神 is the guardian god, attested around 1111; 守護聖人 the Catholic patron saint; 守護霊 the guardian spirit, a word a Japanese spiritualist coined for the English [4].

The text in English. Two dictionaries of 1909 and 1911 give guardian angel as 守護の天使 and date the feast to October 2, the first in English, in the Roman Catholic calender as it spells it, the second in Japanese, 羅馬舊教によれば十月二日, by the reckoning of the Roman old church [5][6]. Kenkyūsha's dictionary of 1929 gives the four characters at last, guardian angel 守護天使, of an individual or of a district, and that is the line the online dictionary's guardian angel descends from; a Sanseidō dictionary of 1948 still wrote the particle [7]. Hepburn has no guardian angel in any of his three editions: his guardian is the legal one, and shugo appears only under preserve in 1867 and under keep, protection and tenable in 1888 [8].

The historical record

The doctrine's two verses. The doctrine rests on two verses, and a Japanese Orthodox catechism of 1909 cites both to a reader who asks whether the guardian angel is in scripture: Psalm 91:11, he will command his angels to guard you, and Matthew 18:10, their angels always see the face of my Father [9]. The Protestant Meiji Bible has neither word at either verse; it says messengers of heaven and his messengers [9].

1896, the Catholic catechism. The phrase came from the missions, and the two missions made two phrases. The Catholic catechism of 1896: Does each person have a guardian angel? Yes; each person has a guardian angel who urges good and turns them from evil, written 守護の天使, the angel of guarding, with the particle [10].

1905, the Orthodox mission. The Orthodox mission's press in Tokyo wrote the four characters solid. In 1905 a translation of John of Kronstadt's meditations tells the reader to remember, when praying alone and downcast, that the Trinity, the holy angels, your guardian angel and the saints watch you with eyes brighter than the sun, the reading shugo tenshi printed over the word [11].

1909, the Orthodox catechism. Filaret's catechism in Japanese asks, Among God's messengers there is, I hear, one called the "guardian angel" who guards a person; is that in the Bible?, the word in quotation marks as a term the reader may not know, and answers with the psalm and the gospel [9]. So the compound is the Nikolai mission's Japanese, and the Catholic Church has kept the particle from 1896 to the present: its pages for the feast of October 2 write 守護の天使 throughout [12].

The feast. The feast itself, as the Japanese Wikipedia has it, was local in the sixteenth century and fixed at October 2 under Clement X [12].

1914 printing, and 1921. Between the catechisms and the dictionaries the word went secular through translation: a critic on Persian art used it for the Zoroastrian guardian spirits [13]; a new religion explained the Christian word to its own believers in 1921: Christianity calls the guardian god by the name guardian angel [14].

1923, and 1924, and 1927. Tolstoy's Cossacks in 1923 toast my guardian angel [15]; a chorus of thirty-five guardian angels walks onto the Oberammergau stage in a 1924 travel book [16]; Hearn's letter in 1927 speaks of one of those guardian angels of legend [17].

Today. In the prewar archive the Catholic phrase outnumbers the Orthodox compound, thirty-one books to fourteen, and the Orthodox word is the one the modern language kept [18].

A reading

Two missions put one doctrine into Japanese in the same decade and made two phrases: the Catholics wrote the angel of guarding with a particle and read angel in the native way; the Orthodox wrote four characters solid, in the Chinese manner their Japanese favored, and printed the Sino-Japanese reading over them. The Protestant Bible, the one most Japanese would meet, has neither. Then the Orthodox word did what Orthodox Japanese rarely did: it became the ordinary word. Translators of Tolstoy and Hearn used it, Kenkyūsha set it beside guardian angel in 1929, the dictionaries and Wikipedia head it, and the fortune-telling sites that come up first in a Japanese search all say 守護天使. A Catholic reader who knows the Japanese feast will notice the missing particle; nobody else will, and the four characters are also exactly the Chinese term. Where 堕落天使 was shortened by the language that received it, this one was kept whole.

References

  1. 「守護」, 精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/守護
  2. 「守護」, moedict. https://www.moedict.tw/守護
  3. 「天使」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/天使
  4. 「守護神」・「守護聖人」・「守護霊」, デジタル大辞泉, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/守護神
  5. 神田乃武・南日恒太郎, 英和双解熟語大辞典, 1909, scan 303 (p. 589). https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/990169/1/303
  6. 新渡戸稲造 等, 英和俗語熟語故事大辞典, 1911, scan 227 (p. 445). https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/902975/1/227
  7. 岡倉由三郎, 新英和中辞典, 研究社, 1929, scan 183 (p. 345). https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1904907/1/183
  8. James Curtis Hepburn, A Japanese and English Dictionary, 1867, 1872 and fourth (1888) eds. Internet Archive japaneseenglishe00hepbuoft. https://archive.org/details/japaneseenglishe00hepbuoft
  9. 通俗正教教話 (ヒラレト, 加島斌 訳), 正教会編輯局, 1909, scan 28 (pp. 44–45). https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/824867/1/28
  10. 公教要理, 天主公教会, 1896, scan 11 (pp. 10–11). https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/824441/1/11
  11. 静思録 (イオアン・セルギエフ, 上田将 訳), 正教会編輯局, 1905, scan 179 (p. 348). https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/824759/1/179
  12. 「守護天使」, Japanese Wikipedia. https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/守護天使
  13. 高山樗牛全集, 1914 printing, scan 41. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/930955/1/41
  14. 大本信徒の主張, 大日本修斎会, 1921, scan 89 (p. 157). https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/919486/1/89
  15. トルストイ, カザツク (訳 加藤一夫), 1923, scan 104. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/979265/1/104
  16. 日高只一, 英米文芸印象記, 1924, scan 181. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/982553/1/181
  17. 小泉八雲全集 第九巻, 1927, scan 50. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1188369/1/50
  18. A local mirror of the National Diet Library's digitized prewar books, searched on nine forms of the word; the counts are held in the research record.

Authors