Fine Japanese Calligraphy

The Art of Master Japanese Calligrapher Eri Takase

花鳥風月 kachō fūgetsu Beauties of Nature

花鳥風月 (kachō fūgetsu) names the beautiful things of nature, and the refined pastime of enjoying and writing about them. It sets two Chinese pairs together, and it is a set expression in Zeami's treatise on Noh by 1402. This study follows it through renga and haikai to an Edo commonplace, and into English.

Abstract

花鳥風月, kachō fūgetsu, pairs two Chinese couplets into one Japanese phrase: flowers and birds, the painter's genre and the poet's spring; wind and moon, the clear breeze and bright moon of Chinese verse. The dictionaries read the four characters two ways, as the beautiful things of nature themselves, and as the refined pastime of enjoying and writing about them, and the oldest texts use it in the second. The phrase is already a set expression by 1400–02, in Zeami's treatise on Noh, and a primer of model letters and a war tale, both of uncertain date near 1400, carry it too; in the century and a half after Zeami a Tendai monk, the founder of a major Buddhist sect and the master of renga each used it for the elegant world a life or a poem is built from, and the haikai poets of the seventeenth century took it up after them. By the Edo period it named a print series, an anthology, a top-spinning game, and even, in a Muromachi tale, two shamaness sisters.

Overview

The sense. The beautiful things of nature, and the elegant pastime of enjoying them and making poems of them; a Japanese pairing of two Chinese pairs, six centuries old. The dictionaries number both senses, and in every text before 1500 read for this history the phrase means the second.

The words. Four characters in two pairs. 花鳥, flowers and birds, is the painter's genre and the poet's spring, in Japanese from the 後撰集 of the tenth century [1]; 風月, wind and moon, is the clear breeze and bright moon of Chinese verse, in Japanese from the 懐風藻 of 751, and by extension the making of poems under them [2]. The pairs are Chinese, and Chinese prose sets the four together by the thirteenth century, but the other way round: Liu Kezhuang 劉克莊 (1187–1269), in a colophon to a friend's poems, complains that the minor poets of his day do no more than set wind and moon against flowers and birds (近時小家數不過點對風月花鳥) [3]. In the order 花鳥風月 the phrase is Japanese: the Chinese texts searched for this history carry that order once, in a county gazetteer of 1928 [4]. The dictionaries read the four as representatives, the first pair of the things one looks at and the second of the scene they sit in, and number two senses: the beautiful things of nature, and the refined pleasure of enjoying them and writing about them [5]. The older Japanese phrase for the same idea is 雪月花, snow, moon, flowers, from a line of Bai Juyi's, and the dictionaries give it as the synonym. The Japanese order is fixed; 風月花鳥, the Chinese order, is written in Japanese too and reads as the same phrase turned around.

The text in English. The phrase reaches English through prints before it reaches it through poetry, in a London sale catalogue of 1912. The literal rendering, flowers, birds, wind, and moon, is the print catalogues' and the reference books'; the scholarly translations of Zeami render his sense instead, suitable elegance and poetry and music.

The historical record

1400–02. Zeami 世阿弥, 『風姿花伝』, second book, on playing a warrior. Zeami, who with his father Kan'ami gave Noh its form [6], writes the oldest dated text, and the phrase is already a set expression for the elegant world a play should be made of. Warrior plays, he says, are rarely interesting: but if you take a famous man of the Genji or the Heike and compose him into flowers, birds, wind and moon, and the play is good, it is more interesting than anything [7].

About 1400, two texts of uncertain date. The 『庭訓往来』, a primer of model letters that the dictionaries date anywhere from the late fourteenth century to the Ōei era (1394–1428) [8], has in its letter for the second month, about a gathering under the blossoms: 花鳥風月者好士之所學、詩歌管絃者遐齡延年之方也, flowers, birds, wind and moon are what the man of taste studies; poetry and music are the way to a long life; the oldest copy read for this history is a manuscript of 1536 [9]. The 『源平盛衰記』, the long reading version of the Heike tale, which the dictionaries place anywhere from the late Kamakura period to the fourteenth century's divided courts [8], says of the warrior Minamoto no Yorimasa 源頼政: 花鳥風月弓箭兵杖、都テコノミト好ム事、名ヲ揚ケ人ニ勝レタリ, flowers, birds, wind and moon, bow and blade: in all he took up and loved, he made his name and surpassed others [10]. Either may be older than Zeami's sentence; neither can be dated closely enough to show it. The war tale's warrior, accomplished in the arts as in arms, is the man Zeami asks a warrior play to show.

1416. Kakōbō Chōben 花光坊長弁, 『私案抄』, a Tendai monk's collection of model letters. A letter of condolence for a dead pupil, dated in its own text, describes what he left: the books and brushes, and the poem-cards and papers from the window of his studies in flowers, birds, wind and moon [11]. The four characters as the name of a young man's literary education.

1477. Rennyo 蓮如, a pastoral letter of the ninth month. The founder of the modern Hongan-ji sect, writing to his followers about the shortness of life: autumn goes and spring goes and the years pass; yesterday is gone and today goes, and we do not notice when age has piled up. And yet in the meantime we must have joined in the amusements of flowers, birds, wind and moon, and met with the joys and sorrows of pleasure and pain [12]. The four characters as the sum of a life's pleasures, in the same breath as its griefs, both forgotten.

1467 or 1470. Sōgi 宗祇, the renga master, 『吾妻問答』. On the opening verse: 發句の事、先は其季の前後をたがへず、いかにもみだりになく、しかも花鳥風月によそへて幽玄の體を心にかけ, as to the hokku: first, do not confuse the season; nothing careless; and, framing it in flowers, birds, wind and moon, keep the mode of mystery and depth in mind [13]. An 1890 haikai writer quotes him more widely: renga is simply this: day and night, morning and evening, to keep always in mind flowers, birds, wind and moon, and the shape of human impermanence [14], a line this history has found only in that quotation. The poet's daily subject, with its shadow.

1664 and 1694, the haikai masters. Matsue Shigeyori 松江重頼, founder of a haikai school: a poet of the way of waka must think of the world's impermanence in the sleepless night, put compassion first, be gentle, never behave harshly even in jest, and discern the feeling of flowers, birds, wind and moon; so the ancients taught in ink [15]. Ihara Saikaku 井原西鶴, of a prodigy: at three, untaught, he wrote the four great characters flowers, birds, wind and moon — the child dies in the next sentence [16].

1829. 『俳諧正語抄』, a haikai treatise printed under the name of Rōka 浪化 (1672–1703). On the hokku's vertical and horizontal: 頭の縦横といふ事縦は竪なり昔より和哥に用来る花鳥風月の定たるをいふ也横とは麺棒摺小木の俗をいふ此故に花鳥風月を俗語になして疵付る事なかれと也, what is called the vertical and horizontal of the head: the vertical is the upright, and means the fixed matter of flowers, birds, wind and moon that waka has used since of old; the horizontal means the vulgar, the rolling pin and the pestle; and so one must not wound flowers, birds, wind and moon by turning them into vulgar words, it is said [17]. The book was printed a hundred and twenty-six years after Rōka's death, from a manuscript said to have been kept at the house of Zushi Rogan 図司呂丸 at Haguro, and Shida Gishū 志田義秀 in 1934 calls it 僞書であらう, probably a forgery [18]. The rule is a witness for 1829, not for Rōka's lifetime.

Muromachi to Meiji, the tale and the commonplace. A tale survives with the four characters as its title, in which 花鳥 and 風月 are two shamaness sisters from Haguro called to a fan-matching party to divine a mysterious painting; they summon Narihira, Genji and Suetsumuhana to speak through a mirror, and the tale is a primer of the Ise and the Genji dressed as a ghost story, surviving in many copies [5]. A storyteller could split the phrase into two women's names, which is a measure of how ordinary it was. By the Edo period it names a comic-poem anthology illustrated by Hokusai, a print series by Kunisada, and a top-spinning game whose eight faces read the four seasons and the four characters; a Meiji proverb collection puts Victor Hugo into it, love uses flowers, birds, wind and moon as its messengers [19]. The National Diet Library's full-text search of its digitized prewar books returns the phrase in nearly three thousand of them [20].

1942. Matsuzaki Kakumoto 松崎覚本, 『揮毫辞典』, a dictionary for calligraphers. Under the phrase: the mind that savors; things enjoyed, and beside it Xie Lingyun 謝霊運's four things hard to have at once, a fine day, a beautiful scene, a mind to enjoy them, a pleasant occasion [21].

The dictionary today. 大辞泉: the beautiful things of nature; and the enjoyment of a refined pastime, 風流韻事 [5]. The examples the idiom dictionary gives are a 1924 novelist and a 1957 wartime officer who sneers that painting flowers, birds, wind and moon in the nation's crisis is a carefree business.

What is not a source. The two Chinese pairs are older than the phrase and are not its source as a set. The Chinese 風月花鳥 is older than any Japanese text read here, but it is rare, it runs the other way, and no Japanese witness cites it, so it is a cousin, not a parent [3][4]. 雪月花 is the elder cousin, not the origin. Xie Lingyun's four things are the calligrapher's dictionary's own pairing, not the phrase's source. The Muromachi tale takes the phrase as its title and is a witness to it, not a source.

The word in English

1912. Sotheby's, London, Japanese Colour Prints, sale of 25–27 March. Lot 281, a sheet by Kikugawa Eizan: Furyu Kwa Cho Fugetsu, "Refined Birds, Flowers, Wind and Moon" [22]. The phrase reaches English as a print series' title, in the Meiji spelling kwa, and the auction catalogues of London carry it from then on.

1923. Walpole Galleries, Japanese Color Prints, New York. An Utamaro titled "Kacho Fugetsu" [23].

1966 and 1980. Jack Hillier, Hokusai Drawings and The Art of Hokusai in Book Illustration. Kyoka Shinsen Kacho Fugetsu Shu, "A New Selection of Kyoka on Flowers, Birds, Wind and Moon," 1824 [24].

1971. The Japan Times. Emphasis on "kacho-fugetsu" meant an emphasis on artistic beauty even in crafts and design [25].

1976. Anne Kent Rush, Moon, Moon. Kacho-fugetsu … comes to mean beautiful natural scenery [26].

1978 and 1984. Traditions and The East, a translation of Zeami. If a play about the Genpei is good and is composed of flowers, birds, wind, and moon, it can be more interesting than anything — the four-word literal [27].

1978 and 1989. Richard Lane, Images from the Floating World and Hokusai: Life and Work. Poems on Birds, Flowers, Wind and Moon; the somewhat wider connotation of "nature art," kacho-fugetsu [28].

1984 and 1986. Rimer and Yamazaki, On the Art of the Nō Drama; Hare, Zeami's Style: the scholarly translations of Zeami. Neither renders the words. Rimer and Yamazaki: when it comes to events dealing with the famous Genji or Heike warriors, if the various elements are knit together with suitable elegance, so that the text is a good one, such a performance can be more moving than one of any other variety [29]. Hare: bring out the connection between him and poetry and music, which Donald Keene quotes in 1993 and glosses: the words are kacho fugetsu, literally "flowers and birds, the wind and the moon," a familiar term for natural beauty but here used for the different arts [30].

1993. Karatani Kōjin, Origins of Modern Japanese Literature. "Flowers, birds, wind, and moon" (kacho fugetsu) [31].

1995. Japan: Profile of a Nation. The beauty of nature, embodied in the term kacho fugetsu ("flowers, birds, wind, and moon") [32].

2020. Matsuoka Seigō, Flowers, Birds, Wind, and Moon: The Phenomenology of Nature in Japanese Culture. The phrase as a book's title [33].

1942 to 2004. The bilingual dictionaries. Takenobu's Kenkyūsha dictionary of 1942, under 花鳥: 花鳥風月を友とする, enjoy (the beauties of) nature; converse (keep company) with nature [34]. Nelson's character dictionary, in its three editions of 1974, 1997 and 2004: kachōfūgetsu, beauties of nature; elegant pursuits [35]. The gloss the house uses is the dictionaries' by 1942, half a century before the 1995 book above.

Today. The four-word literal is how the English reference books and art books name the phrase, and beauty of nature the gloss, while translators of Zeami give his sense in their own words; the house's Beauties of Nature is the dictionaries' own gloss, Kenkyūsha's since 1942 and Nelson's after it. A rendering must keep four things in that order and should let the second sense, the pleasure taken in them, be heard.

A reading

The phrase's story is its age and company: a Japanese pairing of two Chinese pairs, in an order the Chinese did not use, first found in a dated text in the treatise of the man who gave Noh its form, as what a warrior play should be made of, while a primer for boys and a war tale of about the same age already give it as the arts a cultivated man pursues. In the century and a half after, a monk used it for a scholar's window, a sect's founder for a life's vanities, and the greatest renga master for the frame of a hokku; the haikai masters took it up after them, and a treatise printed in 1829 under the name of a disciple of Bashō 芭蕉's makes it waka's fixed subjects, which must not be vulgarized. By the Edo period it was ordinary enough to be a game, a print series and two shamanesses' names. The two senses, the things and the pastime, are both the word's; the pastime is the older, and its first dated home is Zeami's.

References

  1. 「花鳥」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank.
  2. 「風月」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank.
  3. 劉克莊, 「聽蛙詩」 (跋), in 『後村先生大全集』, 卷九十七, folio 13, 四部叢刊 (景賜硯堂鈔本), djvu page 58. https://zh.wikisource.org/wiki/Page:Sibu_Congkan1312-劉克莊-後村先生大全集-48-24.djvu/58 ; the 四庫全書 text, 『後村集』 卷97, 12a, at the Kanseki Repository (KR4d0340). https://www.kanripo.org/search?query=風月花鳥
  4. Full-text searches for 花鳥風月 and 風月花鳥: the CBETA Chinese Buddhist canon, 0 and 0 (https://cbdata.dila.edu.tw/stable/search?q=花鳥風月); the Chinese Wikisource, 1 (『民國大竹縣志』, 1928) and 8; the Kanseki Repository, 0 and 3 (劉克莊, 黃仲元, 王鏊). https://zh.wikisource.org/w/index.php?search=%22花鳥風月%22
  5. 「花鳥風月」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典・日本大百科全書・四字熟語辞典, at kotobank.
  6. 「世阿弥」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典・日本大百科全書, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/世阿弥-85456
  7. 世阿弥, 『風姿花伝』, 第二, 物学条々, 修羅, 1400–02, in three modern typesets: 『花伝書』, 1898, scan 102 (https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/902428/1/102); 能勢朝次, 『幽玄論』, 1944, scan 115 (https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1127093/1/115); 野上豊一郎, 『花伝書研究』, 1948.
  8. 「庭訓往来」 and 「源平盛衰記」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典・世界大百科事典・日本大百科全書・山川日本史小辞典, at kotobank. https://kotobank.jp/word/庭訓往来-99950 ; https://kotobank.jp/word/源平盛衰記-61064
  9. 『庭訓往來』, attributed to 玄恵, manuscript, 天文五年 (1536), scan 5. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2540648/1/5
  10. 『源平盛衰記』, 巻十六, 「三位入道芸等事」: 寛永年間 print, scan 40 (https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2544835/1/40); 『参考源平盛衰記』, 1901, scan 366 (https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/877552/1/366).
  11. 花光坊長弁, 『私案抄』, 応永二十三年 (1416), scan 37. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2533513/1/37
  12. 蓮如, 『御文章』, 文明九年 (1477) 九月二十七日, scan 12. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/820687/1/12
  13. 宗祇, 『吾妻問答』, 1467 or 1470 (the date from 「吾妻問答」, デジタル大辞泉・精選版日本国語大辞典, at kotobank), as quoted by 潁原退蔵, 『俳諧史の研究』, 1933, scan 29 (https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1242668/1/29), and by 能勢朝次, 『幽玄論』, 1944, scan 93 (https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1127093/1/93).
  14. 宗祇, as quoted in 吉本汶蒼, 『俳諧無心の効用』, 1890, scan 17. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/875535/1/17
  15. 松江重頼, 『佐夜中山集』, 寛文四年 (1664), scan 21. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2550657/1/21
  16. 井原西鶴, 『西鶴織留』, 巻四, 元禄七年 (1694), scan 14. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2554438/1/14
  17. 『俳諧正語抄』, 文政十二年 (1829), printed as 浪化's, 泉響園琴而 校, scan 10. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/2540297/1/10
  18. 志田義秀, 「浪化」 附說, in 藤村作 編『日本文学大辞典』, 新潮社, 1934, scan 1285. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1235690/1/1285
  19. 『金諺一万集』, 1891, scan 205; 『明治節用大全』, 1894, scan 282 (naming Victor Hugo).
  20. National Diet Library Digital Collections, next-generation full-text search on 花鳥風月, 2,966 books, 1416 to 1944. https://lab.ndl.go.jp/dl/
  21. 松崎覚本, 『揮毫辞典』, 1942, scans 138 and 159. https://dl.ndl.go.jp/pid/1884879/1/138
  22. Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge, Catalogue of Japanese Colour Prints, London, sale of 25–27 March 1912, p. 40, lot 281. https://archive.org/details/japanesecolourpr00soth_24/page/n49
  23. Walpole Galleries, Japanese Color Prints, exhibition catalogue, New York, 1923.
  24. Jack Hillier, Hokusai Drawings, 1966, and The Art of Hokusai in Book Illustration, 1980.
  25. The Japan Times, October 15, 1971.
  26. Anne Kent Rush, Moon, Moon, Random House, 1976.
  27. Traditions, vol. 2, no. 2, 1978, and The East, vol. 20, no. 6, 1984.
  28. Richard Lane, Images from the Floating World, 1978, and Hokusai: Life and Work, 1989.
  29. J. Thomas Rimer and Yamazaki Masakazu, trans., On the Art of the Nō Drama: The Major Treatises of Zeami, Princeton University Press, 1984, p. 15.
  30. Donald Keene, Seeds in the Heart: Japanese Literature from Earliest Times to the Late Sixteenth Century, Henry Holt, 1993, p. 1018 and n. 79 (p. 1050), quoting Hare, Zeami's Style, p. 185.
  31. Karatani Kōjin, Origins of Modern Japanese Literature, Duke University Press, 1993.
  32. Japan: Profile of a Nation, Kodansha International, 1995.
  33. Matsuoka Seigō, Flowers, Birds, Wind, and Moon: The Phenomenology of Nature in Japanese Culture, Japan Publishing Industry Foundation, 2020.
  34. Takenobu Yoshitarō, Kenkyūsha's New Japanese-English Dictionary, Harvard University Press, 1942.
  35. Andrew N. Nelson, The Modern Reader's Japanese-English Character Dictionary, Tuttle, 1974; John H. Haig, ed., The New Nelson, Tuttle, 1997; Classic Nelson, Tuttle, 2004.

Authors